Auggie - I have to admit, the whole Sunset fiasco fascinates me...it's art, politics, business, all coming together from different angles. Was the best soap opera around for awhile...
The original plan called for Patti to do 3 months in London, then open it in LA (3 months) and then Broadway. What Patti fails to discuss is that she didn't want to do that. So that opened the window for them to look for another actress to open the show in LA. Enter Close.
Part of the difficulty was that their eye was off the ball for LA post-Close. Patti not finding out about not going to NY didn't happen until March 1994... that fiasco sent everyone running in all directions. They had already determined Buckley was succeeding Patti in London - AND - they were shutting Sunset down in London for two weeks to incorporate all the changes to the show (and set) that were done in LA. So they had another "opening" night in London in March or April of 1994.
At that point, they just started to begin mail-orders for Sunset (I remember because I had sent it in the first day they were available) - and I think they were finishing the American Premiere Recording with Close and the LA company.
So all that being said, Faye Dunaway as a replacement I don't think was given the attention it needed... and the PR machine for Sunset was over extended between London and NY. LA was running and running doing very well - but, not surprisingly, ticket buyers were waiting to see and hear who was coming after. I think they must have been overly excited at the thought of an actress of her stature doing the show and thought that like Close, she could get into "vocal shape" for the show. But those early rehearsals must have proven otherwise. And rather than hurt the brand with another embarrassing mess up prior to the NY opening, they were gun shy.
It's too bad that happened. Had she been a disaster, it would've been on her rather than ALW (other than for poor casting). The show in LA closed at a loss anyway, so what if it had played another 4 weeks or so...
Fascinating all around to me