Andrew Rannells Live From Lincoln Center Tonight

Who is watching tonight? The previews look promising!

Damn this is good.

I really hope they hire him for more concerts because he could sing a phonebook and he'd still make it entertaining as hell. I loved the Vicki Carr number, that was the highlight so far in my opinion.

OMG - big fan of Rannells - know he is incredibly talented, but wasn't expecting this. He crushed it. Clever, eclectic, surprising song choice all wonderfully rendered in his unique style--funny and moving. His charm and wit were fully on display--he completely owned that room in a such an inviting way and it came across on television--or more correctly it LEAPT off the television. Whatever vocal imperfections there were here and there, he more than compensated for with his crazy good showmanship. The absolute best of the series-hands down.

Small exception to an otherwise extremely satisfying show-- wish he had not picked "Big Time" to close the show- was a huge let down after such a great set - seemed a little wedding singer-ish and I was shocked given that every other song was just right.

If you are too young to remember the original Vicki Carr version of "It Must Be Him" - Google it so you know just how good and drop dead hilarious his rendition is. Hard to out camp the original but he did.

Hats off.

SmoothLover said: "If they ever do the Glen Campbell story.....just saying...."

Really? Because to me Rannells neither looks, sings nor seems anything like Campbell.
Not saying he might not be able to do it, but your post makes it seem like he's glove-fit for the role and I don't see that at all.

Updated On: 5/12/18 at 05:08 AM

Very surprised by all the comments here. While I agree that Andrew Rannells is very talented, and I was looking forward to the concert as well, I was very disappointed. The song choices were very odd.. why would you pick songs for a PBS special that no one has heard of? In order for these specials to succeed and work in middle America, I think an artist should at least include some of the songs that he's well known for. (Stephanie J Block's special is a perfect example of what I'm talking about). I'm surprised PBS executives approved this set list. If you want to do lesser known pop songs or showtunes, he should pepper the list with some crowd pleasers.

sidebar: he also made strange facial expressions during many of the songs and his closed eyes every time he had to go for a high note. He's usually a good looking attractive guy but this special was not particularly flattering to him.

Sorry, I wanted to love it and I appreciate his talent but this just seemed bizarre to me and everyone watching with me.

I like him okay but I'm glad he didn't beat out Matthew Morrison for South Pacific. No offence.

Why in the world would you think that PBS - or anyone else for that matter would have to approve his set list? That makes absolutely no sense at all.

I enjoyed his show a lot and liked his song choices. Of the four of them I would say Rannells and Stephanie J. Block were my favorites, with interesting set-list choices that were varied between ballads and uptempo songs.

Sutton Foster and Leslie Odom Jr. put me to sleep, sad to say, although Leslie's band was smokin, and I loved the arrangements. Still, for both, I thought the set list was boring, boring, boring.

I've been excited for this season. Finally got a chance to watch Andrew's performance in full. I'm not a great fan of his though felt he was perfectly cast in BOM (the only live production I've seen him in). But that said, I've now been scrolling back and listening to Moon Over Nebraska. My neighbors are probably sick of it! LOL It was the strongest performance of the set. I also liked his Born to Run, and the opening was a good rendition of Lonely Boy. I expected him to do a bit more banter like Stephanie, noting maybe how a younger sister was born and he lost some attention.

The ITW medley was awesome. My favorite SS show so maybe I'm biased, but I really liked it. Clever.

Big Time was a horrible choice for the climax. I guess you don't end with ballads, but I would have ended with Moon Over Nebraska followed by an up tempo arrangement for the bows. Wonder if that's why it looked like only half the room gave him a standing O. I was really shocked. I thought maybe producers asked people to stay seated to not block cameras. Audiences give SO's for everything here. Why not this one-time event being taped for television?

That hair! Really had a mind of its own at times. Such a handsome charming guy, tall and leggy, loved his hair and like the suit ... thought that right collar caught my attention a few times.

The Appel Room is an interesting venue with Columbus Circle and Broadway in the background. Really dramatic.

Well, bummed the series is done. Hopefully there is a plan for one or more seasons! I could see Neil Patrick Harris doing a wonderful gig there.