Kyle4-
I'm going to have to agree with you on a few things with this one. The baptism pool did remind all of my friends of Godspell, and for that reason alone it needs to be cut! As soon as he went down in the pool we all turned to each other and whispered, "Godspell!" I met two other friends at intermission and the first thing out of one of their mouths was, "I guess Godspell isn't the show in town performing baptisms."
I'm sure it was absolutely unintentional and the two productions were unaware what the other was planning, but the fact remains this scene is evoking Godspell. The whole gospel number is bit extraneous, so why not cut it or trim it down? Like the song about driving cars it's a fine song, but slows up the pace.
Both of the moms in the show were the weak acting links. Some of their line readings made me laugh. I was very thankful Frank didn't give either of them songs (I got very nervous during the scene with the tree at night in act two). They were like the poor man's Cass Morgan in Memphis.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!