Wish we got to meet! I love meeting BWW people. The majority of my friends, while theater folk, are not nearly as "obsessed" as we all are.
After Eight, I hardly think it's bland. But I do agree with Whizzer that it is certainly uninspired. It's not as great as I'd hope (personally, I'd like to see the Meryl Streep/Greg Kinnear B&C at the end of that comedy... the Siamese Twins one.... I can't remember the name. Anyway...) but I really enjoyed it.
The cast is magnificent. I would love to see this run for a bit. Definitely not in my top 25 (though Jeremy's performance might be...) but I enjoyed it very much.
"I know now that theatre saved my life." - Susan Stroman
iluvtheatertrash- SPOILER- Hobson did become the sheriff at the end because the original sheriff was killed during the shoot out in the previous scene.
AfterEight- I think you were pretty spot on with your comments. It did lack some grit and excitement. I know this isn't an adaptation of the movie, but the film is a lot more exciting.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!
To each their own, but Laura and Jeremy can't touch the performances given by Jan Maxwell and Danny Burstein right now, imho. I don't think they are shoe-ins, or necessarily even contenders for the Tony right now. Definitely too early to be throwing that around!
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!
SPOILER: I was a little disappointed, as much as I loved the song, that "Dyin' Ain't So Bad" was not actually one of Bonnie's poems. Especially with the fact that they suggested it was after reading us so many of her poems throughout the night. Would've loved to have heard one of them set to music.
[How great would a "Story of Bonnie & Clyde" be?]
"I know now that theatre saved my life." - Susan Stroman
AfterEight, you honestly didn't hum any of the songs as you left the theatre? I find that hard to believe. You must not really like music.
As far as merch goes, they had all the stuff mentioned before, but what caught my eye was this weird metal coffee mug that I kinda want to go get. I try to get something (usually a magnet) from each show I see.
I liked Danny, but I really didn't like Jan. Don't want to threadjack and I know I'm in the minority, but as a huge Jan Maxwell (and Phyllis Rogers Stone) fan, I left very disappointed.
I don't know about Laura and a Tony, but Jeremy is pretty extraordinary and carries this beast. Amazingly talented young man...
"I know now that theatre saved my life." - Susan Stroman
Theatertrash - I swear it was briefs but I was in the orchestra and pretty far back and the stage was dark so I could have missed it. Either way I agree he was VERY hot in this show. In Newsies I wasn't sure if he was even attractive but damn he's gorgeous.
Scratch and claw for every day you're worth!
Make them drag you screaming from life, keep dreaming
You'll live forever here on earth.
iluvtheatertrash- SPOILER The did make a reference to it in the scene where Hobson had assumed the position of Sheriff. One of the other detectives said something like, "tell that to the old sheriff, sheriff" when Hobson suggested they try to arrest the pair rather than shoot to kill.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!
I got a rush ticket at 5:45 tonight and ended up in B10 in the orchestra. It was stamped partial view but I could see basically everything.
I really enjoyed myself and was beyond pleasantly surprised by how good I thought it was. I think a lot of the score is strong and beautiful, but there are definitely songs than can be cut because, like Whizzer said, they slow down the pacing. I'll echo the previous thoughts that Louis Hobson's song should be cut, it just doesn't serve a purpose at all, he sings it well, but it's irrelevant.
The casting of Laura and Jeremy is absolutely perfect. They both sing the crap out of the score and have incredible chemistry. And they make a very pretty couple as well and play off each other quite well.
Melissa Van Der Schyff was another major standout for me. I think she brought a lot of intensity to her role and she has a very unique voice that I wish she could have showcased more.
Overall, I really enjoyed myself, though, I do think act one needs to be tightened and paced up more. I'm excited to go back in a few weeks and see what changes have been made, though, because I really do predict good things for this show based on what I saw tonight.
Oh. Yikes. I may have spaced for a moment. I TOTALLY missed that and spent ten minutes VERY confused.
And heck yeah, Jeremy was hot hot hot. I was in row M all the way to the side, but I'm pretty sure I saw some butt cheeks. And I was looking for 'em, not gonna lie. By that point, I'd been totally seduced by Jeremey's Clyde. And if he was getting out of the bath, I was going to FOCUS.
"I know now that theatre saved my life." - Susan Stroman
Let me ask this. Based on what everyone has stated so far, is it fair to say that as a whole people are giving mixed to positive reviews of the show at this realy stage?
AfterEight, I guess I spent too much time with the recordings on the site and liked the songs before going in...
I will agree with you that the secondary characters are sooo uninteresting and the set is very dark. I just like to point out the positive side of things. lol
I did get ahead of myself in saying that the 2 leads need Tonys. I just really liked them.
First, you really need to lean how to write. Second, you need to lean how to write reviews. You don't mention a single person's name, you talk more about yourself then the material and I didn't learn anything except that there are planka of wood being used for the set.
What a waste of 'e-space'.
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it?
These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
Kyle4- I'm going to have to agree with you on a few things with this one. The baptism pool did remind all of my friends of Godspell, and for that reason alone it needs to be cut! As soon as he went down in the pool we all turned to each other and whispered, "Godspell!" I met two other friends at intermission and the first thing out of one of their mouths was, "I guess Godspell isn't the show in town performing baptisms."
I'm sure it was absolutely unintentional and the two productions were unaware what the other was planning, but the fact remains this scene is evoking Godspell. The whole gospel number is bit extraneous, so why not cut it or trim it down? Like the song about driving cars it's a fine song, but slows up the pace.
Both of the moms in the show were the weak acting links. Some of their line readings made me laugh. I was very thankful Frank didn't give either of them songs (I got very nervous during the scene with the tree at night in act two). They were like the poor man's Cass Morgan in Memphis.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!