"Maybe not in the words Bobby used, but with the contemporary Broadway being as it is, her voice is NOT what people are used to, unfortunately. It reminds me of another singer I didn't like for a small period of time and then I hit myself on the head and was like "wait, THIS is real singing"[...]But then I see all of the people that love her, or love... Stephanie J. Block... or... *thinks* Carollee Carmello, maybe, and I feel a bit better. There's a place for pop and it shouldn't be Broadway, and it upsets me that the big people on Broadway are doing so much poppy stuff because they feel they need to appeal to the masses."
THANK YOU. Steph's is one of the names that popped to mind when you said this; I really do think that the people who like her tend to like Patti, and vice versa (I'm not saying there's a 1 to 1 correspondence, just that there are some similarities).
"Anyway, Patti LuPone...
You need to see some sort of video of Sweeney, honey, because you're really not getting it."
YESSS. Ditto PASSION (I DID like her Fosca) or EVITA. "A New Argentina" and "Rainbow High" in particular give me chills every time. She truly inhabits every role she plays.
That said, I think we're going to have to accept that pop musicals are here to stay, and that they represent a new genre. Good news? Maybe the pop musicals will serve as a "gateway" that leads to the hardcore stuff! And, honestly...it's not the people who love Idina who bother me; that's a matter of taste. It's the people who say "Idina is great and Stephanie sux" or "Bernadette rocks; Patti is hideous"...OR "Newbie, you're an idiot because you only know WICKED."
Can we all at least agree that it's still better than reality TV?
Updated On: 9/6/06 at 01:47 PM