SteveSanders said: "2.5 stars from Chris Jones at the Chicago Tribune for Brokeback Mountain at Chicago Shakespeare Theater.
https://www.chicagotribune.com/2026/06/05/review-brokeback-mountain-chicago-shakespeare/"
Yeah, we saw it a few weeks ago and it's not good. Amazing set design, and I was actually seated next to the set designer. However, this did not work at all. It felt like it was maybe at one time supposed to be a musical, but that didn't work, so this hybrid situation of a play and songs was created. For me the songs, just stopped the narrative cold and didn't really add anything to the piece.
The two leads were fine, with Jack Cameron Kay giving the stronger performance as Jack. For me, the best performance came from Cordelia Dwendy as Alma.
My biggest issue is that I never felt the tragedy. I never had the feeling of many years passing, which is vital to the tragedy of the story. This may be one of the few times where I felt they should have had younger and older versions of the leads. By the time we get to the tragic end, I just didn't feel much of anything.
I would be shocked if this moves to NYC. If it does it is going to require some huuuugee names as the leads.
In better theater news, I did just see Catch as Catch Can at Steppenwolf and if you want to see some insane feats of acting, go see this show. It stars 3 actors doubling up on roles as parent and child. There is a Christmas scene in this show that has to be at least 10 minutes long where they are playing these multiple characters simotaneously. Its crazy impressive and thrilling. The play itself is okay, I have to admit there were moments where I was confused what was going on. But to see these 3 performances take on this challenge is worth the price of the ticket alone.
I'm seeing Iceboy! on the 27th, can not wait.