PipingHotPiccolo said: "...Bernthal and Hecht are both truly excellent, and rise above the uneven tone. Im baffled why Ebon Moss Bachrach agreed to do this role, and I suspect the most rewriting/agita took place with respect to his character. Hes given nothing to do and his character is so underwritten, such a misfire..."
Hecht was quite good. Bernthal and Moss Bachrach were huge disappointments to me, albeit for different reasons. We've heard the term "disappeared into the role" used before, but Moss-Bachrach took it a step further and just plain disappeared, depriving the play of one of its most potentially impactful characters. Bernthal, on the other hand, shouted his way through a manic performance devoid of nuance. These two have done beautiful work together on The Bear and individually, Bernthal in particular, in many other projects.
I don't blame them. More likely they are casualties of a poorly written adaptation that didn't have the right director. The production was the misfire.