I'm surprised at how "small" Meryl looks in the role. And by "small" I don't mean "in stature," I mean "in presence."
Cherry Jones was a force of nature on stage. A larger than life nun who took over any room or situation she was in.
Meryl looks more cunning and calculating. A strong woman, but not a "wall" of virtue. More like a weasel than a lion.
...and I'm not sure how well that's going to work overall. We'll see...
With Cherry Jones, you had the feeling you were facing the entire "church" and everything it stood for. With Meryl, it's more like your fighting a bitter old nun.
She may be more "human" than Cherry (theatrical) Jones, but it might actually shrink the story down, as a result. I want this to be a larger-than-life person facing larger-than-life issues.
I agree with those who say it just doesn't feel quite right.
I'm surprised, on the other hand, how good Hoffman looks. He's still not my first (or second or third) choice for the role, but he seems to have inhabited it very well.
Amy Adams looks great, but that character IS an observer, and she doesn't seem to be observing the colossal battle of the stage show. This is playing more like a battle between normal people, rather than "institutions of thought."
Yeah, that's a lot from just a trailer, and I look forward to seeing the whole movie.
And I hope it goes beyond my "okay" expectations of it, after having seen this.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22