What actors can you see in what roles? Can you think of any celebrities that could pull any of them off? I know there's a few threads about Bobby leaving/Brian joining and the general N2N thread but this one is just for cast ideas. Can anyone else see Gavin Creel as Dr. Fine/Madden?
Diana: Alice Ripley
Dan: Johnny Depp
Gabe: Justin Bieber
Natalie: Mylie Cyrus
Henry: Corbin Bleu
Dr Fine/Madden: Matthew Morrison
Like omg! I luvz N2N it iz my LIFE!!!! ZOMG I totes wish every1 should see this show! I am sooooooo Diana!! Lolz! Ok brb, ttyl- Twlight is on! Team Jacob yey!
Diana: Dame Edna Everage
Dan: Wallace Shawn
Gabe: Jm J Bullock
Natalie: Lea Delaria
Henry: Babe the Talking Pig
Dr Fine/Madden: Stewie Griffin
Diana: Patti LuPone (after plastic surgery to take 25 years off her)
Dan: Raul Esparza
Gabe: Cheyenne Jackson (after plastic surgery to take 15 years off him)
Natalie: Lea Michele (omg I <3 Glee!)
Henry: Christopher Mintz-Plasse (his audition sealed it with his post-pot giggle)
Dr. Fine/Madden: Justin Timberlake ("walk with me, rock your bodee!")
Julia Murney as Diana, Christian Borle as Dan (even though he's younger than her), Maybe Chris Seiber as Dr. Fine/Madden, John Groff as Henry, haha, or even Noah Weisberg even though he is and looks WAY too old! He's just adorable and I'd love to see it, maybe in Miscast or something. Maybe Harley Jay as Henry, too. Andy Mientus as Gabe, and shoot, IDK who I'd want to play Natalie. I don't care.
Toni Collette as Diana with Raul Esparza as Dan.
Understudy Joined: 12/16/07
Diana- Julia Murney
Dan- Brian d'Arcy James
Gabe- Michael Arden
Henry-Bobby Steggert
Natalie- Lea Michele
Dr Madden/Fine- Raul Esparza
Diana: Sarah Palin
Dan: Ellen Degeneres
Gabe: The Olsen Twins, alternating scenes
Natalie: Varla Jean Merman
Henry: Elizabeth Berkley
Dr Madden/Fine: Dr. Joyce Brothers
Diana: Barbara Cook
Dan: Tom Wopat
Gabe: Norm Lewis
Natalie: Vanessa Williams
Henry: Chip Zien
Dr Fine/Madden: Cubby Bernstein
Cubby Bernstein! It is to laugh.
This could go on all day, as far as I'm concerned.
I'd pay $100 to see Cubby Bernstein give Barbara Cook electroshock therapy.
Jordan, I really wish your avatar would either swallow or spit in in a napkin. I am sure Todd doesn't enjoy the drama.
I'd really like to see Lewis Cleale as Dan.
Diana: Elaine Stritch
Dan: Michael Crawford
Gabe: Lee Roy Reams
Natalie: Orfeh
Henry: Michael Ball
Dr Fine/Madden: Sam Harris
Diana: Toni Braxton
Dan: Eddie Murphy
Gabe: Andy Karl (gabes dead, who cares!)
Natalie:Rebecca Naomi Jones
Henry: Josh Henry
Dr. Fine/Madden: Douglas Hodge!
Diana: Tyra Banks
Dan: Miss J Alexander
Gabe: Nigel Barker
Natalie: Janice Dickinson
Dr. Fine/Madden: Jay Manuel
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/30/09
In all seriousness, I think if Meryl Streep was a bit younger, she would be good as Diana. She is a very talented actress, and a name that would attract an audience that would otherwise not be interested in the show after Alice leaves. We heard her sing in the Mamma Mia movie, and even if she can't quite handle the demanding score of Next to Normal, I would be forgiving assuming she acts the role very well and boosts ticket sales. Unfortunately, I think she's getting too old to play 39-42, so it seems really unlikely.
Jordan wins.
I'm picturing his cast as those big heads on the doors of the theater.
To go along with Jordan's cast, Nole Marin (and Empress Minnie) as Henry.
Diana: Sutton Foster
Dan: Neil Patrick Harris
Gabe: Kyle Riabko
Natalie: Lea Michele
Henry: Jonathan Groff
Dr Madden/Dr Fine: Cheyenne Jackson
Diana: Sherie Renee Scott
Dan: Norbert Leo Butz
Natalie: Vanessa Ray
Gabe: Christopher Fitzgerald
Henry: Jon Groff
Dr Madden/Fine: Will Swensen
sutton foster as natalie
also i think Steph. J. Block would be a great diana
I second Stephanie J. Block as Diana. That would be amazing. I also second Christian Borle as Dan. Mainly because I love his voice. Hearing the two sing together would be too great for words. I like Bobby Steggert as Henry a lot too. Kyle Dean Massey is my favorite Gabe. I haven't the slightest idea for Natalie...
Videos