(minor spoilers ahead)
Overall gotta say it was good. Not great. But I guess they still have some time to work out.. whatever. I'd say it is still definite must see theater, but not as good as the Alda/Schreiber version.
Some things:
- A good section of the audience around me groaned at the line "houses flooded' during Roma's pitch in act 1. (i.e Sandy) Interesting whenever real life events intercede with the script.
- Bobby was fantastic. Big big fan of his. I still prefer Liev's version of Roma, but Bobby's first act closer was dynamite. Woke everyone up. Should definitely be major Tony buzz for his performance if the show can pick up some good buzz. He was a lot showier and flamboyant than I've seen it played, especially around Lingk. He had everyone in the audience buying what he was selling tonight.
- David Harbour as Williamson was my favorite Williamson I've seen. I remember him from Merchant of Venice too, but the humanity he brought to Williamson was truly remarkable. He doesn't play him like the 100% dick that Spacey does, but rather gives Williamson a heart. You believe and feel the struggle he's under. Thought he really did fine work.
- Mcginley and Schiff were both solid. The roles don't call for too much, but they filled them nicely. Mcginley played Moss underhanded which was a nice choice, rather than yelling his way out of the show like most Moss's do. Shamos as Lingk good too.
- The transitions in between scenes of the first act were a bit cheap in my opinion. Seemed rather tacky. The shade trick at the beginning of act 2 was a nice touch.
And unfortunately I get to this:
- WTF was Al Pacino doing? He was serviceable, but nothing that great. Almost every time he was part of a scene, it virtually stopped the show. Seriously lost any momentum the show was carrying. His first act scene was slow, but (i thought) deliberate on the part of Al in order to build a nice arc for the character. But other than a hilarious crumb cake bit after closing the sale, Shelly was the worst part of the show. i didn't care about him like I did for Alda/Lemmon's Shelly. He never seemed that particularly desperate, but more like the crazy weird old guy who works at your job (First thought is Creed from the Office). Not the former Roma of the office. Having him at the center of the show, you want to care about Shelly and I didn't really.
- Not to mention it seemed like Al went up on his word a couple times, although I checked the script and turns out he didn't. But that's how slow he went. Ginormous fan of his, but it seems that no one gave Al any direction this time. Odd.
- Also if anyone was their tonight (Friday), anyone see Pacino make an odd face when he bowed at curtain? Maybe it was just me.
But still the show was still entertaining and it's Mamet. Go see it.
Updated On: 11/2/12 at 10:26 PM