Great songs in flops

There are some flops with music that is, well, mediocre. Let's talk about the flops and the songs that stand out as one of the best (especially if the entire score is the best part of the show).

CARRIE - I'm Not Alone, Heaven, Carrie, And Eve Was Weak (very WICKED-like)
THE MAGIC SHOW - Goldfarb Variations, West End Avenue, Two's Company, Lion Tamer
HIGH FIDELITY - Top 5 Breakups, Nine Percent Chance, Conflict Resolutions, Turn the World Off
MY FAVORITE YEAR - everything!
ANYONE CAN WHISTLE - Everybody Says Don't
ALL AMERICAN - We Speak the Same Language, What a Country, Melt Us!
IT'S A BIRD, IT'S A PLANE, IT'S SUPERMAN - You've Got Possibilities
CHESS - One Night in Bangkok, The Arbiter, Merano, Quartet, Pity the Child, and the "Chess" theme - such a good song to play on piano
SMILE - Until Tomorrow Night, A Typical High School Senior, Disneyland
SWEET SMELL OF SUCCESS - The Column, Dirt, Welcome To The Night, and others
METROPOLIS - Nothing Really Matters

---

I think you picked some of the weakest songs from Chess. I think Where I Want to Be, Endgame, and The Deal all stand out a lot more than songs like The Arbiter and Merano.

Also, I think Turn the World Off (or whatever the song was called) from High Fidelity was incredibly weak; Number Five with a Bullet and She Goes both deserve to make your list.

Mr. President - The Secret Service, They Love Me
Nick and Nora - Boom Chicka Boom, Men, Anything better than Dancing
By Jeeves - It's a Pig, That was Nearly Us, Travel Hopefully
1600 - Just about everything in the score is stellar, but especially Take Care of This House, Sonatina and the Monroviad
Allegro - Gentleman is a dope
Breakfast at Tiffany's - Travelin', Lament for ten men, Quiet Coffee, Home for Wayward Girls, When Daddy Came Home, You've Never kisse her, Stay with Me, grade A treatment
The Entire Score of Candide, as well as The Capeman (you can see im going in alphabetical order now)
Celebration - Somebody, Not my problem
Do I Hear a Waltz - Moon in my window
Magic Show - Solid Silver Platform Shoes, Three Company
Martin Guerre - Live with Somebody you Love
Merrily - almost the whole damned thing
Minnie's Boys - Mama a Rainbow
Yeston's Phantom - Home
Dear World - I've never said I love you
The Rink - Colored Lights, Don't Aah Ma Me, The Apple Doesn't Fall, Wallflower
Romance, Romance - Words he Doesn't Say,
Snoopy - Poor Baby

That's all I can think of right now..

---

BY JEEVES - Travel Hopefully, It's a Pig (I agree with you on that)
CAPEMAN - Everything
MERRILY WE ROLL ALONG - Everything
STEEL PIER - Everything
DEAR WORLD - I've Never Said I Love You
THE GRAND TOUR - You I Like
HIGH FIDELITY - She Goes, Number Five With a Bullet (maybe you're right)
BIG - Fun, Cross The Line, Coffee Black, Dancing All The Time
MERLIN - Beyond My Wildest Dreams
A BROADWAY MUSICAL - Smashing New York Times (they cut that from "Applause" the first time)
DANCE OF THE VAMPIRES - Eternity, Logic, There's Never Been a Night Like This, For Sarah, Carpe Noctem

---

HIGH FIDELITY had a beautiful song that was sung on the demo by Sherie Rene Scott titled "Perfect." You can hear it as sung by Julia Murney on her solo CD, "I'm Not Waiting."

CANDIDE- "Glitter and Be Gay"
THE RINK- "Don't Ah Ma Me"
ANYONE CAN WHISTLE-It'd be easier to list which songs aren't great in this brilliant show.
SONG & DANCE- "English Girls," "Come Back Wih the Same Look In Your Eyes"
THE ACT-"Arthur in the Afternoon"
CAROLINE OR CHANGE-The whole show
MACK & MABEL-"Wherever He Ain't," "Time Heals Everything," "Look What Happened to Mabel"
SEESAW-"Nobody Does It Like Me," "He's Good for Me," "I'm Way Ahead."

---

Glad I'm not the only one who loves "More of the Same" from BALLROOM, though it sounds like it could belong in MAMMA MIA.

---

CARRIE - And Eve Was Weak, Unsuspecting Hearts
THE ACT - The Money Tree
DRACULA - Life After Life
MARTIN GUERRE - Working On The Land, I Will Make You Proud, The Imposter Is Here, Bethlehem
JEEVES - Half A Moment (Before it lost a part of the melody to SUNSET BLVD's "As If We..."), It's A Pig
THE BEAUTIFUL GAME - God's Own Country

I don't quite get how Carrie is anything like Wicked. The music in Carrie (at least mother/daughter songs) is quite darker and more grandiose in scale, while Wicked tends to go for more of a pop sound.

Lennon - Had some great vocal arrangements for all songs

Brooklyn - the score was generic but 'raven' was good and 'once
upon a time' was impressive in what Eden did 8 times a week (without killing herself)


Merrily - Our Time, Good Thing Going, Not a Day Goes By

HOW NOW, DOW JONES- "Step to the Rear", "Shakespeare Lied"
SUBWAYS ARE FOR SLEEPING- "Once in a Lifetime", "I'm Just Taking My Time"

THE MAGIC SHOW most certainly wasn't a flop. Ran for over 1,900 performances, was the fifth longest running musical from the 1970s (After A CHORUS LINE, GREASE, ANNIE and PIPPIN) and was Stephen Schwartz's third hit show in a row (After GODSPELL and PIPPIN)

---

Definitely agree with the scores of "Sweet Small of Success" and "Steel Pier" but i think "At the Fountain" and "Running in Place" from the respective shows deserve special mention.

Also, the Little Women score was VERY hit or miss but i think "Here Alone" and "The Fire Within Me" were spectacular.

And Side Show. That score is banging. Except "Rare Songbirds..." and if you've seen or been in that show the "double hot dog" part of "Beautiful Day For A Wedding" is wow. beyond ridiculous. But i love that show. Ok, I'm done.

---

Mack And Mabel: I Won't Send Roses

---

"Also, the Little Women score was VERY hit or miss but i think "Here Alone" and "The Fire Within Me" were spectacular."

Dito - I loved Astonishing and The Fire Within Me, and I thinkg "Here Alone" was simply gorgeous and heartbreaking.

Actually, although I find the score overall a little dull, it's very pretty (with a few standouts) and seems very appropriate for Little Women.