Has anyone else noticed an increase in “nose breathing” by performers on Broadway?

I’m noticing that instead of taking an inhalation through the mouth during a song, more and more performers are keeping their mouth closed and inhaling through their nose during a song.

I know the nose breathing is for vocal safety to prevent drying out, but it looks (and sounds) so unnatural to me since people don’t really inhale through the nose before speaking in real life.

Wondering if others notice it as well.

Updated On: 3/6/26 at 01:13 PM

excuse me

hmm, what is someone breathing through their nose when making this thread?

Ensemble17591322022 said: "SteveSanders said: "hmm, what is someone breathing through their nose when making this thread?"

It’s okay if you don’t know what I’m talking about. Some people will."

Apparently no one has yet.

Ensemble17591322022 said: "SteveSanders said: "hmm, what is someone breathing through their nose when making this thread?"

It’s okay if you don’t know what I’m talking about. Some people will."



Crickets.

JSquared2 said: "Ensemble17591322022 said: "SteveSanders said: "hmm, what is someone breathing through their nose when making this thread?"

It’s okay if you don’t know what I’m talking about. Some people will."



Crickets."

There was an example posted several minutes before you wrote this 😅😅😅😅

Mary_Poppins said: "Ensemble17591322022 said: "so unnatural to me since people don’t really inhale through the nose before speaking in real life."

So I don't exist or at least I'm unnatural? You've got me worried a little.

Seriously, I only inhale through the mouth when I'm near death after running too much. Which I never do."

This gentleman may be exaggerating to make the point, but it seems it’s uncommon to do so:

https://youtu.be/PZG431ii-9E?t=81&si=kq6XN5aegJi-7tya

Updated On: 3/6/26 at 06:15 PM

If it had been a staple of vocal performances since the dawn of time, and if it was something I’d heard all my life, maybe it wouldn’t be so jarring. But it’s extremely jarring to me, both in sound and visual. There’s a lot of head and neck movement involved in taking a deep nasal breath.

So yes, it is a suspension of disbelief too far, because it’s not at all a match with the visual and aural world that has been established. And if you watch from the start of the video, he said it took him out of the moment. Will singers start doing nose breathing during book scenes as well, to keep it consistent?

If Broadway voices got by just fine without nose inhalation for 100 years or so until now, maybe something needs to be stopped rather than added.

If it doesn’t bother you, wonderful. Maybe if enough of it happens, it will become more obvious.

Updated On: 3/6/26 at 07:07 PM

Mary_Poppins said: "[...] why does Youtube shove this self-inflated MickeyJo guy in my face whenever I watch anything Musical related?"

He does come off as being pretentious.

Would you consider him to be a "mouth breather"?

Mary_Poppins said: "If it's uncommon then what's your problem?

If you're worried because it's increasing, maybe vocal coaches other than the guy in that video have been re-evaluating it and found it more advantageous than previously thought.

And what would you consider more important: vocal safety or some rather subtle sound difference. I mean, semi-randomly breaking out into song complete with glory notes and all that in the middle of a conversation isn't very realistic or natural to begin with but some nose breathing is one step too far for you?

Also, why does Youtube shove this self-inflated MickeyJo guy in my face whenever I watch anything Musical related?"

Was with you until your weird reacition to MickeyJo. The way algorithms work, if you are clicking on a lot of musical theater links, he's probably going to show up in your feed because--wait for it--his content is amost entirely about musical theater. Doens't seem self-inflated to me. He loves talking about this, so he does. He's gotten popular, so he's invited to many shows as a critic. Watch him or don't--I like some of his videos, not others--but your aren't exactly Alex DeLarge strapped to a chair with clamps to keep your eyelids from closing while MickeyJo videos are paraded before you for hours.

joevitus said:

"Was with you until your weird reacition to MickeyJo. The way algorithms work, if you are clicking on a lot of musical theater links, he's probably going to show up in your feed because--wait for it--his content is amost entirelyabout musical theater. Doens't seem self-inflated to me. He loves talking about this, so he does. ."

I know about "algorithms". But that full of himself moron is way over-represented on my Youtube even though I've long stopped watching him. Watched him exactly twice, both times not to the end. It's not like he posts 10% of all Musical Theater content on YT. Something's wrong with the algorithms, thus my question.

You could have roughly figured that out yourself instead of going on a bizarre tangent about Alex DeLarge.

Mickey Jo seems like a very humble and kind guy. Odd that anyone would have such a negative reaction to an innocuous person. I totally understand why people loathe Sweaty but Mickey???

Mary_Poppins said: "joevitus said:

"Was with you until your weird reacition to MickeyJo. The way algorithms work, if you are clicking on a lot of musical theater links, he's probably going to show up in your feed because--wait for it--his content is amost entirelyabout musical theater. Doens't seem self-inflated to me. He loves talking about this, so he does. ."

I know about "algorithms". But that full of himself moron is way over-represented on my Youtube even though I've long stopped watching him. Watched him exactly twice, both times not to the end. It's not like he posts 10% of all Musical Theater content on YT. Something's wrong with the algorithms, thus my question.

You could have roughly figured that out yourself instead of going on a bizarre tangent about Alex DeLarge.

"

If you're going to whine about something shoved in your face all the time, as if an act of violence if being perpetrated on you, I think you've earned an Alex DeLarge analogy.