Home for the Holidays is one of the most inept shows I have EVER seen on a Broadway stage. It was an embarrassment not only for the performers, but also for the audiences members stuck watching this cringe-fest. To their credit, many fled throughout the last half hour of this 90 minute debacle.
The three reality show winners had ZERO charisma, ZERO chemistry with each other, and two out of the three of them also couldn't sing, which is pretty rough for a concert.
Bianca Ryan committed a hate crime against the English language by refusing to only sing vowels; she made up for this by also refusing to resist any run until the melody was completely obscured. She thought she was Mariah. She so, so badly wanted to be Mariah. But we can't always get what we want.
Josh Kaufman was stiff as a board and showed as much personality range as Lurch.
Candice Glover can definitely sing, but it was like she was in the recording booth rather than in front of a live audience with whom she could interact.
No one is credited with direction nor do I think anyone directed this mess. Songs ended and the singers walked off stage. No transitions.
Song choice was also not a strong suit. No we do not need to hear all 14 verses of The First Noel riffed to high heaven. (Have you ever noticed that each verse of Christmas carol seems to get Jesus-ier and Jesus-ier? It wouldn't surprise me if there was some fundie/mega church money behind this thing.)
I did have several uncontrollable fits of laughter, especially when Danny Aiello claimed- with a straight face- that these were some of the greatest voices of a generation! I mean, I was at Brigadoon last night, buddy. Don't make this worse by lying to us.
There's a sign out side that says start a new holiday tradition- well let me tell you, if the comatose audience tonight was any indication, this will be one very short lived tradition.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!