Just got back from tonight's preview and oh boy do I have some thoughts.
First of all... Brynn O'Malley has GOT to go. I don't get the appeal of her at all - she's such an "adequate" performer. She's fine, she's okay... but I could list 20 other actresses that would be fantastic in the part. I hate being this cold toward performers but man I kept thinking "what a missed opportunity".
I have to agree with everyone else who has said that show is just "okay", because it is. It's not great, but it's not bad. But I'm having a hard time understanding how JRB went from Bridges to... this. I appreciate his versatility but I can't find his signature in this at all. It sounds like an attempt at Cy Coleman's style mixed with Shaiman and Wittman. It's easily accessible, completely commercial... but just somehow misses the mark at being great.
The show needs to be funnier somehow. All of the jokes got tepid laughter. Nancy Opel is working her ass off with her material but by the end it's just not funny anymore. Rob McClure is fantastic but deserves better, and Tony Danza is... fine. He was exactly what I expected.
"A Little Luck" needs to be rewritten or cut - the action flat out stops with this song when the show could really benefit from a push here. I loved Tony's tapping and it was a nice surprise, but it should either be placed somewhere else in the show or with a more upbeat song. The show could speed along excitedly into its ending if the song was gone but instead we get another midtempo one.
I thought the orchestra was fantastic and the set was nice, the projections didn't bother me except for the Flying Elvis's "landing".
Oh also, the singing at the end of the bows should be cut too. We had a sporadic standing o (maybe like half the orchestra stood up?) for when Rob and Brynn took their bows, but then the cast starting singing and it was that awkward moment where we could either clap along, or sit back down. Most of us sat back down.
I think the show really has potential - I feel like these are such easy fixes and hopefully they are working on them. I had a lot of fun tonight but I just keep thinking how much better the show could be.
Also, Gaelen Gilliland needs a raise. She's completely owns it as an ensemble performer and her singing in the "Airport Song" is a stand out.
Updated On: 12/3/14 at 11:48 PM