Mike Barrett said: "I’m frankly too much of a Potter nut to like her and root for her so I simply cannot imagine her as Dolly Levi.
That being said, I had no idea she was in musician theatre. I wish them the best. Not a Rudin production I assume? "
She’s been in Follies, Gypsy, and Sweeney Todd just in the last few years
And she won the Olivier Award for Into the Woods in 1991 (as Baker's Wife).
I think this is great casting personally and I don’t get the negativity about Imelda. Not only is she a great actress she’s also got great comedy chops. I think she’ll be fab
Agreed. Just because she's been cast in more emotionally intense roles doesn't mean that's all she's capable of doing.
Oh dear gawd! What's next?
Imelda as Nellie Forbush?
Imelda as Maria?
Imelda as Squidward?
Yes, because that would be the logical procession regarding any actress in their 60s who has played two or more of the following roles: Adelaide (Guys and Dolls 1983 & 1996), Dorothy (Wizard of Oz 1987), Baker's Wife (Into the Woods 1990), Mrs. Lovett (Sweeney Todd 2012), Rose (Gypsy 2015), Sally (Follies 2017). While you're at it, why would think she would accept Squidward over Spongebob, anyway?

"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian