logan2---I don't think you fully understand that without two key names: Meryl Streep and Johnny Depp, there would be no film version of Into the Woods being made right now.
They were the reason that Disney gave it the green light. Why? They are both box office draws, and their track record of (fairly) recent hit films far outweighs any of their misfires. They are as close as the movie business gets to a "good bet."
None of the other actresses you listed have the same box office clout that Meryl Streep does. Actually, very few do, currently. This has nothing to do with what anybody thinks of her enormous talent, this has to do with her bankability.
Because Meryl and Johnny signed on, Rob Marshall finally got Disney to say "yes" to the whole thing. That's the way it works.
I know many people growl about Madonna in "Evita," but it was the same thing back then. You either got a film version of Evita starring Madonna, or you got nothing. Many names were bantered about for that role, but the project never got off the ground. Too many reasons to say "no." Finally, when Madonna signed on, it went into production.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22