Posted: 10/5/18 at 11:11pm
Okay, here goes.
The good:
The puppet, the puppet, the puppet. It's almost insulting to call it a puppet...it's the most emotive, moving, REAL performance in the show. It is also possibly the best piece of technical stagecraft I have ever seen. Watching the operators fly around on their cables as they bring it to life is thrilling; watching its extraordinarily expressive face and eyes is breathtaking; watching it lean out over the front rows before rearing up to full height is jaw-dropping. Kong justly received the final curtain call, and a well-deserved standing ovation. Some of the related stagecraft, including use of projections, is also very effective.
The bad:
Pretty much everything else.
Oh, the costumes are lovely, and the choreography is energetic and athletic (if at times weirdly placed), and the performers are in fine voice and try to do their best with the material they are given. But Jack Thorne's book makes his script of Cursed Child (hated the book, loved the production) look like Pulitzer material. Cliches everywhere, clunky exposition, "jokes" that fall dead, and a complete absence of real character development or pathos. The songs are unmemorable...any one or more of them could be deleted and I probably wouldn't notice on a second viewing...and often end oddly and abruptly. And the lyrics are generally painful ("I watched you fall out of the sky/I am not prepared to say goodbye" - really?).
Am I glad I saw it and sprang for a premium seat? Actually yes...that's how effective the technical wizardry is, and I'll remember it for a long time. I just wish it were all in service of a better show.

