Hushpuppy and best12bars, thank you for refreshing my memory of the staging. Of course you are right: I was confusing "I Put Some Make-Up On" with "I Am What I Am". (I'm talking about staging only; I didn't mix up the songs themselves.)
For the record, I've always thought the supposed Herman/Sondheim feud did a disservice to both. The basic premise undervalues Herman and turns Sondheim into some sort of pretentious snob, unfairly in both cases.
***
best12, did you see MARCH OF THE FALSETTOS in L.A.? I didn't, but it's always struck me as odd that MARCH closed quickly at the Doolittle (yes?), while a waiver production of IN TROUSERS ran for months and months. In NYC, the runs were almost exactly the opposite.
I'm asking because I don't understand how the characters could possibly be "cliché" for musicals. When had there ever been characters like them on a musical stage?
Even now, I still ponder at some of Finn's imagery and what it tells us about the people in the play.
***
Regardless, my opinion is my opinion. To me, the musical LA CAGE substituted American-style sentimentality for the original biting, European farce. In the process, the piece became both less funny and less moving, despite the lovely songs PJ was kind enough to list for us.
But I am well aware that mine is a minority opinion.
***
Oh and BTW, Sondheim's lyric about "they want a tune they can hum" is NOT a slam against Rodgers except in After Eight's tortured imagination. Sondheim is satirizing the many people who told him (Sondheim) that his music wasn't hummable.
The proof? The melody sung by the producer is exactly the same melody he has just heard in the boys' audition: "I like to live in New York..." So the "hummable" melody is the same as the allegedly unhummable melody. That's the joke and it has nothing to do with Rodgers.
Updated On: 7/26/13 at 07:51 PM