Aren't all of the broadway houses too big for Scottsboro really? I mean, I get that many people here love that show (personally, I didn't when I saw it in previews), but I always thought part of the problem is that it doesn't have the mass appeal (for lack of a better term) to consistently fill a broadway size house of 1000 or more seats 8x a week.
Back to topic, I think it's more of a shame about the St. James being empty than the Belasco given it's location and the fact that aside from the super-devoted fans (aka people who post here) probably don't even know what street the Belasco's on. For the record, not knocking the Belasco but most of the east of Broadway houses don't get the foot traffic the ones west of broadway do.
2010: Next to Normal (May 25), Hair (Jun 9), American Idiot (Sep 10), Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson (Sep 26), The Scottsboro Boys (Oct 17), Fela! (Nov 14), Next to Normal (Dec 30)
2011: That Championship Season (Feb 15), La Cage Aux Folles (Mar 16), The Book of Mormon (Mar 16), Anything Goes (Mar 30)