"""I became a fan of Rachel's from The Last Ship as well.
"I am completely against her potentially joining the Broadway company."
Can I ask why? Were you also completely against the other times we brought the West End Elphabas to Broadway? "
First, "against" might have been the wrong word to choose. She just would not have been my choice to select as the the next replacement. For the some time now, I feel that Wicked has been going through the motions with their casting, i.e. pulling people from the tour or people who were formally with the production. I was over the moon when Lindsay Mendez, Jenni Barber, and Kara Lindsay were cast in their roles because I felt that since they had never done their roles before that new life would be brought into the company. In addition, I feel that Wicked is closing themselves from new talent if they keep bringing in people from the tour or if they have been with the production before. Many actresses have said that they want to play Elphaba or Glinda and I think that these actresses won't get that chance if Wicked keeps going with what they are doing. However, I do understand that auditioning takes time and it would be easier for them to just do a shorter rehearsal process with them instead of a longer rehearsal time. In the end, I just would like someone new.
"
Kara Lindsay did play the role before on the 2nd National... She took over from Hayley Podschun."
I know Kara Lindsay took over for Hayley Podschun on the 2nd National. But, that was the 1st time she performed the role. Therefore, she was new to the material.