I went this morning for the rush around 9:45. I ended up being 9th in line. By the time I got to the front, they only had one seat in the front row, so we got box seats.
For what it's worth, I asked the woman if she could give me second row or side orchestra, but she said that she doesn't have as much leeway as she did before so it's pretty strict to front row and box seats.
(Another update) - I took a few friends this morning (5/6) to do the rush and we ended up getting there about the same time as last time (9:40). Only I guess the Tony nominations had a big effect. There were about 30 or so people in front of us, so the rush tickets were long gone by the time we got to the front. We opted to get the last row mezzanine though since the theater is so small.
Updated On: 5/6/09 at 01:50 PM