Skywalker3 said: "iluvtheatertrash said: "anti-semitism"
There it is.. Anti Zionism isn't anti-semitism..
It is not about being a Jew, it is about begin pro Israël.
As far as we know now, Noah isn't pro Israël (anymore).
"
1) The overwhelming majority of Jews in the world identify as Zionists.
2) When your anti-zionism is rooted in falsehoods that generalize Israelis and all Zionists as "evil", you're practicing in hatred and libel against Jews.
3) When you continue to be "anti-Zionist" while refusing to understand what Zionism actually is to Jews across the diaspora, while Jews are under attack for "anti-Zionism" around the world, you're practicing in anti-semitism.
4) When you refuse to understand that Zionism does not mean you support the Israeli government's actions, you're being ignorant and blaming all Zionists (again, the overwhelming majority of Jews around the world) for the government's actions.
5) When you take the stance of an "anti-Zionist", it means that you do not believe the Jews have a right to exist in their ancestral homeland. That you do not believe Jews have a right to a safe place to call home. MANY Zionists want a two-state solution for peace. Anti-Zionists do not want Jews to have any home in that land, and deny them their ancestry to the land. This is anti-semitic, and a denial of our history.
6) When you condemn, attack, harass and bully a young American Jew for being a Zionist, despite the fact he has condemned the current Israeli government and its leader, despite the fact he has criticized the government's actions during this war, you're being an anti-semite. Because you are expecting a Jew to entirely turn his back entirely on his people, his ancestral homeland, his faith. Folks here regularly condemn Trump and our current government in America - but no one is being attacked for simply being an American. Or believing that America still has a right to exist. There's only one group being attacked in the name of criticism of the Israeli government - and that's Jews. Not just Israeli Jews, but ALL Jews.
Over the last nearly 3 years, anti-Zionism has absolutely become anti-semitism. And why is that? Ignorance, mostly. A failure to understand what Zionism actually is, and a conflation of Zionism with Netanyahu. Zionism is older than Netanyahu, and the modern state of Israel.
You can keep telling yourself whatever you want so that you can get to sleep at night. But when you attack a Jew for being a Zionist without bothering to do any deep-diving into their feelings on Israel's current government and its actions, you're being an anti-semite.
And yes, Noah is still "pro-Israel". He still believes it has a right to exist, and that Jews have a homeland there. One can be "pro-Israel" but not "pro- the current Israeli government".
"I know now that theatre saved my life." - Susan Stroman
Updated On: 8/19/26 at 09:25 AM