Finally saw it yesterday y'all....in the words of that tumblr..."How do you botch Prince of Egypt??" SERIOUSLY THOUGH...Honestly, I don't have much to add as everything wrong about this has already been said. I have a few more I could add, but I don't think it's necessary. It's either super underwhelming or outright BAD. The only things I can forgive are the lone trumpet to start the show off (THANK GOD, if that wasn't done, there would have been no hope for the rest of it) and the fact that Scottie boy didn't go story theatre "story-in-a-story" format with this. This story only needs to be shown, THAT'S IT. There's NOTHING extra needed in terms of changing things up, because the film already does the work of some of the best through storytelling, complex characters we can actually care about and/or root for, Schwartz's magnum opus of his compositions...I just don't understand how creative teams are missing the mark on so many new shows these days!
Just do what the shows needs to be good, don't try to be "oh so different" from it's source that audiences love, find the shows's identity, run with it and done with it!! They want so much to be different from the source material to be "new and different", that this idea fails...trying too hard is a sure way to have a flop. Sometimes new and different isn't what's needed for the shows integrity, and creative teams better figure this out fast other wise we'll have a crap ton more flops that could be hits on our hands.
I went with my family, and as I have in the past, I didn't tell them anything about these things I'd been hearing so as they could decide for themselves. When we all told each other our thoughts, they surprisingly agreed with everything I said in response to their own thoughts, as to explain to them WHY they think the show is weak, design is bare and underwhelming, actors miscast but also dealing with terrible writing, etc. More thoughts came today and they each have said in some variant, "The more I think about it, the more I almost hate it because we all know and love this movie, the movie is GREAT, and obviously this show could be great too! What went wrong??" This is my family who aren't necessarily experts and only really know what they know because they've seen me wade though this business and learn what good art is. No prompting from me and they still are immensely disappointed and at times shocked at how this potential major hit, could miss the mark so completely. The audience reaction at curtain call said it all too. Almost no one in the balcony (where I sat) stood at all (not that they should have anyway but you get the point) and from what I could see in the orchestra, not too many people were enthusiastic down there either. It was a VERY lukewarm response everywhere.
This show packs no emotional gut punch whatsoever, has too much extraneous moments that have no bearing on the story at hand about two brothers in a broken relationship, orchestration was thin, sound quality was thin (multiple potential reason for this), almost everyone was miscast in this, though there was some better casting than others, but NO ONE was completely right for their role, none of the new songs were great, One of Us was a COMPLETE oddball and not in a good way, and I could go on about the story format and structure problems and very misguided and juvenile writing and mishmash of staging styles that Scottie has come up with...I hate avant garde where it shouldn't be used but, if you're going to go that direction then go full force, but don't mix with traditional staging, and even that was just boring and undynamic. The film is a highly emotional and HUGELY powerful piece that gob smacks you with walloping feels, and this show has none of that, it has nothing going for it whatsoever.
Whoever said this was better than B and the B...I'd LOVE to know what you're smoking, because I'm tempted to get some of it myself, because maybe this show would have been more enjoyable that way. Then again, I wouldn't want any because I don't want artistic standards to slide either.
If the rumor is correct that they don't have Broadway plans for this, then so be it because if this is their end product then this has no right be moving forward at all. But if they do...they better fix this then, because this tripe will get panned for sure. The Brits would have a filed day if this were over there...I don't regret seeing it, because I've been waiting and waiting fro years to finally see this masterpiece come to the stage, but that's the only reason I'm glad I went, is to say I saw it.
Updated On: 10/22/17 at 09:30 PM