I saw it the night NYAdgal saw it and was knocked out. The staging is extremely inventive, and the performances are exquisite, especially Celia Keenan-Bolger as Molly (the Wendy character) and Adam Chanler-Berat (who was so spectacular in Next to Normal) as the Peter character.
It's pretty much my favorite thing-that-wasn't-hyped-before-I-saw it in a very long time.
It's also my favorite thing-that-takes-off-from-a-classic-work-that-stands-on-its-own-apart-from-the-classic-work-yet-captures-the-true-spirit-of-the-classic-work in a very long time.
I'm going back with my bf on Saturday and I bought tickets as a birthday present for a friend. (If he sees this thread, the surprise will be ruined, but it will give him something to look forward to until he sees it, the day before his birthday.)
Seriously, if you love Peter Pan, don't miss this show.