I was quite vocal of my dislike of Cyclone when it was Off-Broadway at MCC, and I thought its faults were pretty much unfixable. I don't even think it's particularly dark and edgy, unless you think Hot Topic is dark and edgy.
It's a show that's been kicking around for a while (since 2008, apparently), and when shows do that, they tend to not actually improve, but rather make a lot of sideways moves.
Kad, I couldn't agree more- I was also very vocal about my dislike. I think the problems are unfixable right down to the casting, those choices are basically set in stone after 8 years with almost the same crew, it's almost hard to believe anything new or fresh coming from those involved at this point. The fact it's still kicking around I don't think is necessarily helping it. Maybe a new director can help minimally, but the material is what it is, and none of the performers give me hope of evolving- it's hard not to think they're walking through it at this point with it being so in their bones, it's easy to fall back on old habits. Emily Rohm was the bright spot for me.