Rachel York played Reno at Reprise! in LA, so there is certainly room for more sex appeal in the role. Would love to see her "reprise" it on Broadway.
Beauty, belt, comic chops, AND tap dancing. Didn't see her in Anything Goes, but did see her in My One and Only. The girl can shuffle ball change!
I can certainly understand going with Reba, though. While not quite "right" for Reno, I think she will be very energetic and entertaining. She's supposed to be a former religious evangelist who has turned to nightclub singing, so I think Reba's country roots could be quite plausible. Her "Blow Gabriel Blow" could have a real Gospel feel to it.
And she'll sell a passle of tickets!
Rachel York at Reprise!