Posted: 5/24/20 at 10:04am
qolbinau said: "''It holds up the way 'Citizen Kane' holds up,'' says Mr. Sondheim of the show now. ''Every scene is juicy. The characters are vivid. The songs are sharp and entertaining. You can't get bored in 'Citizen Kane' and you can't get bored in 'Gypsy.' I can hear someone saying it's a vulgar show or an obvious show but not that it's a boring show.'' There is a bit of Kane as well in the driving, pioneer's energy that prevents Rose's character from becoming a hateful Mommie Dearest. ''The fact that she's monstrous to her daughters and the world is secondary,'' says Mr. Sondheim. ''She's a very American character, a gallant figure and a life force.'' He quotes one of Rose's lyrics from ''Everything's Coming Up Roses'' -- ''And nothing's gonna stop us till we're through!'' -- and adds, ''Everyone has to feel that and identify with it and go with it.''
He still marvels at his mother's self-delusional take on the show itself: ''She said, 'You know, Steve, there are mothers like that.' I couldn't believe it -- my jaw opened.''"
Thank you for sharing this! I had never read it or heard his comments before and they're so spot on.
To throw in my 2 cents, I agree with matt1982. The Laurents production got incredible performances out of Patti, Boyd and Laura. Laurents directed the hell out of that book. A musical comedy that descended into a greek tragedy.
That said, I also agree Mendes' production had more flair, took more risks, and was more visually interesting.
And I hate choosing who is "better," truly. Patti was born to play the role and mined it for everything it was worth. (Frankly, I don't understand people who say they like the show and didn't like her - that's Rose.) Peters is a really great actress and pulled it off, despite being miscast IMO. She's such a strong actress, I believed her each step of the way, but I never believed those giant songs wanted to come out of her. The seductive or more comedic ones, yes. But simply not the way that, say, a Patti just opens her mouth and "Everythings' Coming Up Roses" falls out.
