* count me as an avid theatre goer who's gone back a second time. My parents came into town wanting to see something, and after seeing the first preview, I reccomended this.
I'll admit, I have some problems with the show, but way less than I did with any of his other musicals since Phantom. Even the score, when it's not the best, is ridiculously hummable and catchy. The kids and Alex are giving tour de force performances.
The first time I saw it, I thought that "Where Did the Rock Go" was a missed opportunity. This should be the fun number where the Principal lets her hair down, dances on the bar, and earns her Tony Award for an off the wall take no prisoners comedic number. While I still wish we'd gotten that chance, the number that's there is still pretty good. And it wasn't the number I'd initially expected going in. In a musical based off of a hit movie with only a small amount of possible surprises to offer, this moment did surprise me.
but the weirdest thing for me was Sierra. On the first preview, her awkwardness garnered a ton of laughter, and I honestly thought she was giving a solid performance. Last Tuesday night? It was awkward watching her. Very few of her jokes in the first act landed, and only in the second half did she really get any real love from the audience.
that being said, given the enthusiastic audience response, and my parents asking me when they'd get to see it again, I think this is Andrew's best chance at a commercial hit in years. It's no Phantom in terms of spectacle or cohesion, and no Evita in terms of innovative storytelling, but it rocks. It rocks hard.
Updated On: 12/6/15 at 09:25 AM