"OK so maybe I should change my statement, The shows that I wouldnt WANT to go see are Q and SPelling Bee, Ive LISTENED to both albums and I didn't like either, therefore if I went I would most likely walk out at intermission, does that satisfy you?"
Not me, not really. Listening to a cast album just doesn't give you the full experience of the show including hearing the songs in context - in the world of the show. There have been quite a few shows that I heard the cast album for first and didn't care for it at all and then, when I actually saw the show, became completely captivated by it and went back to the CD with a new perspective on the score. There have been shows that I've loved the cast album and then found when I saw the show that the songs didn’t really work for me in the context of the show.
So I don't think it is fair to say that you would "probably" walk out of the show when you really haven't experienced the actual show. Personally, I'm not a huge Ave Q fan, and I certainly have no desire to own the recording since I think listening to those songs outside of the context of the show would drive me batty. But overall, the show as a whole works very well and I can't imagine someone not being at least mildly entertained by it as an actual "live" entertainment. I like Spelling Bee quite a bit, but I think I would be hesitant if I knew it only from the recording since (although I'm a huge William Finn fan), I think the score is the weakest part of the show.
Yes, yes, it's your opinion and you can say whatever you want and blah, blah, but personally, if I were thinking about seeing a show and you said to me something like "I heard the CD and I think I would walk out of it if I saw it" I don't think I would give too much weight to your opinion.
And that's just my opinion.
Updated On: 7/22/05 at 11:00 PM