No, I thought Johnny Depp was quite good. Sweeney has a reason to brood. It was playing Mrs. Lovett exactly the same that ruined the property. What fuels the show is Todd's irrational (though understandable) thirst for vengeance v. Mrs. Lovett's irrepressible optimism.
It wouldn't surprise me if the original approach to Lovett was a collaboration between Prince and Lansbury. Perhaps Sondheim really thought a different approach might be interesting. If so, he was wrong.
My original point is that when you have two dominating characters, playing them as psychic twins isn't a great approach.
Updated On: 9/9/14 at 07:51 PM