I grew up with and adore Hearn's performance, and I'm sad I'll never know Cariou's beyond the OBCR... which, honestly, I don't listen to all that much. But I don't listen to any SWEENEY recordings "much."
CHURCH DOOR TOUCAN GAY MARKETING PUPPIES MUSICAL THEATER STAPLES PERIOD OIL BITCHY SNARK HOLES
I saw Cariou and was 13 at the time and remeber it as "one of the last Shows" where they really sang full out, not like 99 out of 100 now where thsy are "protecting" their voices and on "vocal rest" (not that I have a real problem with it). Cariou had the evil thing down cold! He is on the TV show Blue Bloods now and every time I see him I chuckle to myself that he was Sweeney...
I assume that most people in this thread are familiar w/ the soundboard recording from the opening night performance of the original production? It's absolutely thrilling hearing an audience experience Sondheim's score for the first time.
I have not seen Len live, but this wonderful live footage of him and Angela...gem! The one I posted is not the entire performance, but it is a clip of the rest of the footage on YouTube.
HorseTears, I haven't heard the opening night soundboard, but, as I said, I saw an early preview (the Judge's flagellation scene was still in) and was shocked that music so "operatic" could also be so accessible. SWEENY was definitely not a show where I wished I had heard the album in advance.
Walking in cold--but with great trepidation because of the subject matter--made for one of the great theater experiences of my life! (And, again, I apologize if it seemed I was criticizing you for liking George Hearn. I think he's terrific on the DVD.)
My husband and I watched and enjoyed the concert, but we sat down last night and listened to the OBCR (the 2-CD set with some dialogue) and couldn't help but notice how much better it was, vocally and dynamically.
You think? The more I think about it, the more I want to forget about how bland and unpolished it was.
Listen, I don't take my clothes off for anyone, even if it is "artistic". - JANICE