Posted: 6/2/22 at 11:05am
Saw the show last night, and really loved just about every part of it. Having seen the Public and original Broadway productions years ago, there was a certain alchemy in that original cast that really made the show shine. I saw a lot of that in parts of this production.
Firstly, maybe it's because it's late in the run and some of the meh responses to Williams were in previews, but I thought he was fantastic. Daniel Sunjata is hard act to follow, but Williams is really fantastic. I'd argue that if it wasn't his Broadway debut, he might actually win the Tony over Ferguson because while wonderful, there's a long shadow that Denis O'Hare leaves. There are certain lines that O'Hare just served to perfection, and to hear those same lines kind of used as a throw away, I wonder if Tony voters who remember those will be thinking similarly. But then there's Oberholzer, who manages to just go for broke at Shane, just unrelenting emotionally, he's his own mini tour-de-force, hopefully a star-making performance. Really, any of them could, and should, win the Tony.
The newly added scene, while I get why, it's more a should they have? It just didn't really do anything except give Williams some more meaty material. But really, it didn't work for me.
The rest of the cast was wonderful, and the intimate theatre was a great choice. My seats were 2nd to last row center, and they were great. A simple, affective set, really highlighted the performances. (And of course, the, um, performances.)
I will say the Yondr process was a bit confusing, I thought you could leave it on in the case, but they were telling us to shut them off, but then didn't say that we were already about to give them to lock up. I'll admit I had a brain freeze trying to remember how to turn it off! But once in, I didn't mind not having the phone with me.
"Hey little girls, look at all the men in shiny shirts and no wives!" - Jackie Hoffman, Xanadu, 19 Feb 2008