The bottom line is that the work has that "it" factor. Impossible to describe. The book for the stage show is really quite terrible, though the organization of plot (also by Lindsay and Crouse) is exceptionally good. While some people love the two songs for Max and Elsa, and they are fun, they don't fit the characters (for instance, neither Max nor Elsa are really selfish, so the lyrics to No Way to Stop It don't fit them; similarly, Max seems to be fine with Elsa and Georg marrying, but he pointlessly needles her with How Can Love Survive). Yet, the show, to put it mildly, works.
And the superior movie really, really, really works. You can mount any sort of intellectual argument against it, but it gets to most everyone.
Everything about it just works. Someone started a thread about what musical we'd most like to see survive all others, but it may be that the musical that will survive all others is this one.
Updated On: 9/16/20 at 03:11 AM