As I've said in a few threads, I very much prefer separate threads for Previews and then Reviews. When I think about shows, I frequently go back and reread old threads. Sometimes I'm interested in the pre-opening changes, so I'll stick to the previews thread. Sometimes I'm interested in the professional reviews and post-opening responses once the show was frozen (because reading about things no longer applicable to the show aren't what I'm looking for). It's easier to have specific threads so I know exactly what I'm looking for. Also, for popular shows with a lot of discussion, putting everything in a single thread will make it incredibly long and difficult to find something, especially given the unreliable search feature on the board.
For the past several years, I've been one of the people posting the opening night reviews, searching for them as they are posted to the various sites, quickly scanning them for a relevant blurb, and posting the title, blurb, and link. I usually have not created those threads.
jacobsnchz14 used to create the opening night threads, and I would post the reviews in them. For instance, here's the Cabaret thread from 2024.
https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/CABARET-at-the-Kit-Kat-Club--2024Opening-Night-CriticsReviews
Or here's the Company thread from 2021, which ljay889 started, "as the other thread is extremely long."
https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/Company-Reviews--and-beyond
At some point EDSOSLO858 took up the mantel and would create the reviews thread, and I would post the reviews in his.
https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/REAL-WOMEN-HAVE-CURVES-Reviews
(There was one time when I started a separate Reviews thread when one had already been started, but that was because the original had already become bogged down in several pages of bickering and arguing before the first review was even posted (as people started offering their predictions on what the reviews would be, and then others argued, etc. etc). So by the time I had the first review, I just started with a new thread for a clean slate than post it on page 3 of a thread filled with bickering. If I remember which one it was, I'll add the link.)
Everything was fine until recent months, when another poster started competing to start the Reviews thread, often after EDSOSLO858 had posted one. So there would be multiple threads, one of which would eventually come out on top.
On Tuesday, at the top of Page 3 of The Fantasticks preview thread EDSOSLO858 suddenly announced, "At the request of multiple users, I will start to consolidate preview and review threads for Broadway shows." and changed the title of his thread to Previews + Reviews. I'm not sure why he or the users who apparently requested it get to unilaterally make that decision, but I replied that I would continue to post the reviews in their own thread, the same way they had always been, for the reasons I mentioned at the top of this post. For what little it may be worth, my comment did receive more positive votes than his announcement, so it seems like there was interest in having a separate reviews thread (though one poster did become abusive and demanded everything be in a single thread). CoffeeBreak had in fact already created a separate reviews thread 12 hours earlier, so I did post the reviews there.
https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/THE-FANTASTICKS-Previews/3
https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/THE-FANTASTICKS-Hayes-Broadway-Reviews
Last night the ever competitive CoffeeBreak, who had started the previews thread for Much Ado About Nothing, changed the title of the thread from previews to "Previews + Reviews" like EDSOSLO858 had done with The Fantasticks. When I was ready to post the first review, there was no dedicated reviews thread the way there has always been, so I started one and began posting the reviews there, the same way I always have, in their own thread. Some users evidently considered it bizarre to post reviews the exact way we have been for decades (and the abusive poster from the Fantasticks thread reemerged to harangue anyone who thinks reviews should have a separate thread), but there it is. It wasn't about being the first one to create a thread. If anyone else had already started one, I would have used it. But there was not, and I very much believe it's worth having a reviews thread that starts with the opening night reviews and then continues the discussion of the show post-opening from there.
If there's widespread agreement that there should only be one thread for every single post about a show, then so be it. (If anything that seems like it would make things more insular and lead to less engagement, but others claim to know better.) I'm not sure how having two threads, one for previews, one for reviews, is clogging the boards or why people can't simply disregard the thread they're not interested in, yet here we are. But surely it isn't up to a small group of posters to unilaterally make that decision, demand everyone else abide by it, and harass them if they don't?
Updated On: 11/20/26 at 02:24 PM