Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
#1

The show thread war

I have been around here for a decade (first under bear88) and didn’t know this was a thing until it’s suddenly blown up.

I am accustomed to the old system (rumors of show threads, official announcement and ticket buying thread, previews thread, and reviews thread that turns into the de facto show thread after opening) but there is a push for single, all-purpose show threads. I’m not sure what has prompted this (Theatreboard in the UK uses the single show thread system) but it has prompted one of my least favorite things on this board: a heated controversy about message board organization that overwhelms any discussion of the show itself.

I am creating this thread in the naive hope that this squabble can be discussed here and not in the preview and review threads. I am not clear if this is being pushed by moderators, a few aggressive posters, or some sort of collective consensus of the board that is getting pushback.

While I have a preference, I can live with either system. Can someone explain how this started without undue antagonism for those who disagree, and make the case for either system?

#2

Re: The show thread war

Thank you for starting this discussion. The antics in recent days have been quite annoying.
I would also ask does it matter who starts these threads? Is there some kind of special honor or recognition for starting a popular thread? The behavior of some folks would lead you to think so. I say who cares who starts the threads. A consistent system is preferable.
#3

Re: The show thread war

I don’t understand why we can’t keep all of the discussion relevant to one show consolidated to one thread (member reviews from previews and after opening, along with professional reviews) but that’s just me.


Some members of this board seem to be strangely competitive about separating the conversation and starting new threads that just clog the board. It’s weird.

Updated On: 11/20/26 at 01:39 PM

#4

Re: The show thread war

Agree with the above.



Furthermore, the mods on here are so arbitrarily quick to delete certain posts, but let this stupidity of a thousand different threads dedicated to the same exact topic continue. Will never understand.

Updated On: 11/20/26 at 01:44 PM

#5

Re: The show thread war

I am also used to the traditional 2-3 thread breakdown you mentioned, created by whomever has taken up the torch of doing those things.


But it does feel like in the last couple months, creation of those threads has stepped on already active discussion threads covering those topics and the board has just become overly cluttered with the same discussion happening across multiple active threads.



Generally I think it should be a common sense/read the room type thing rather than trying to impose one’s will on how and where people discuss something.


"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."

Updated On: 11/20/26 at 01:48 PM

#6

Re: The show thread war

My bad if I'm exacerbating the issue at all.


Imagine if we could tell everyone here that Liberty Mutual customizes car insurance to save people hundreds. (LiMu squawks)
#7

Re: The show thread war

I stopped creating threads at the right time I’ll tell you what.
#8

Re: The show thread war

As I've said in a few threads, I very much prefer separate threads for Previews and then Reviews. When I think about shows, I frequently go back and reread old threads. Sometimes I'm interested in the pre-opening changes, so I'll stick to the previews thread. Sometimes I'm interested in the professional reviews and post-opening responses once the show was frozen (because reading about things no longer applicable to the show aren't what I'm looking for). It's easier to have specific threads so I know exactly what I'm looking for. Also, for popular shows with a lot of discussion, putting everything in a single thread will make it incredibly long and difficult to find something, especially given the unreliable search feature on the board.

For the past several years, I've been one of the people posting the opening night reviews, searching for them as they are posted to the various sites, quickly scanning them for a relevant blurb, and posting the title, blurb, and link. I usually have not created those threads.

jacobsnchz14 used to create the opening night threads, and I would post the reviews in them. For instance, here's the Cabaret thread from 2024.

https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/CABARET-at-the-Kit-Kat-Club--2024Opening-Night-CriticsReviews

Or here's the Company thread from 2021, which ljay889 started, "as the other thread is extremely long."

https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/Company-Reviews--and-beyond

At some point EDSOSLO858 took up the mantel and would create the reviews thread, and I would post the reviews in his.

https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/REAL-WOMEN-HAVE-CURVES-Reviews

(There was one time when I started a separate Reviews thread when one had already been started, but that was because the original had already become bogged down in several pages of bickering and arguing before the first review was even posted (as people started offering their predictions on what the reviews would be, and then others argued, etc. etc). So by the time I had the first review, I just started with a new thread for a clean slate than post it on page 3 of a thread filled with bickering. If I remember which one it was, I'll add the link.)

Everything was fine until recent months, when another poster started competing to start the Reviews thread, often after EDSOSLO858 had posted one. So there would be multiple threads, one of which would eventually come out on top.

On Tuesday, at the top of Page 3 of The Fantasticks preview thread EDSOSLO858 suddenly announced, "At the request of multiple users, I will start to consolidate preview and review threads for Broadway shows." and changed the title of his thread to Previews + Reviews. I'm not sure why he or the users who apparently requested it get to unilaterally make that decision, but I replied that I would continue to post the reviews in their own thread, the same way they had always been, for the reasons I mentioned at the top of this post. For what little it may be worth, my comment did receive more positive votes than his announcement, so it seems like there was interest in having a separate reviews thread (though one poster did become abusive and demanded everything be in a single thread). CoffeeBreak had in fact already created a separate reviews thread 12 hours earlier, so I did post the reviews there.

https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/THE-FANTASTICKS-Previews/3

https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/THE-FANTASTICKS-Hayes-Broadway-Reviews

Last night the ever competitive CoffeeBreak, who had started the previews thread for Much Ado About Nothing, changed the title of the thread from previews to "Previews + Reviews" like EDSOSLO858 had done with The Fantasticks. When I was ready to post the first review, there was no dedicated reviews thread the way there has always been, so I started one and began posting the reviews there, the same way I always have, in their own thread. Some users evidently considered it bizarre to post reviews the exact way we have been for decades (and the abusive poster from the Fantasticks thread reemerged to harangue anyone who thinks reviews should have a separate thread), but there it is. It wasn't about being the first one to create a thread. If anyone else had already started one, I would have used it. But there was not, and I very much believe it's worth having a reviews thread that starts with the opening night reviews and then continues the discussion of the show post-opening from there.

If there's widespread agreement that there should only be one thread for every single post about a show, then so be it. (If anything that seems like it would make things more insular and lead to less engagement, but others claim to know better.) I'm not sure how having two threads, one for previews, one for reviews, is clogging the boards or why people can't simply disregard the thread they're not interested in, yet here we are. But surely it isn't up to a small group of posters to unilaterally make that decision, demand everyone else abide by it, and harass them if they don't?

Updated On: 11/20/26 at 02:24 PM

#9

Re: The show thread war

MemorableUserName said: "(There was one time when I started a separate Reviews thread when one had already been started, but that was because the original had already become bogged down in several pages of bickering and arguing before the first review was even posted (as people started offering their predictions on what the reviews would be, and then others argued, etc. etc). So by the time I had the first review, I just started with a new thread for a clean slate than post it on page 3 of a thread filled with bickering. If I remember which one it was, I'll add the link.)"

I seem to recall that was for BOOP!, MemorableUserName.


Imagine if we could tell everyone here that Liberty Mutual customizes car insurance to save people hundreds. (LiMu squawks)
#11

Re: The show thread war

MemorableUserName said: "As I've said in a few threads, I very much prefer separate threads for Previews and then Reviews. When I think about shows, I frequently go back and reread old threads. Sometimes I'm interested in the pre-opening changes, so I'll stick to the previews thread. Sometimes I'm interested in the professional reviews and post-opening responses once the show was frozen (because reading about things no longer applicable to the show aren't what I'm looking for). It's easier to have specific threads so I know exactly what I'm looking for. Also, for popular shows with a lot of discussion, putting everything in a single thread will make it incredibly long and difficult to find something, especially given the unreliable search feature on the board.

For the past several years, I've been one of the people posting the opening night reviews, searching for them as they are posted to the various sites, quickly scanning them for a relevant blurb, and posting the title, blurb, and link. I usually have not created those threads.

jacobsnchz14used to create the opening night threads, and I would post the reviews in them. For instance, here's the Cabaret thread from 2024.

https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/CABARET-at-the-Kit-Kat-Club--2024Opening-Night-CriticsReviews

Or here's the Company thread from 2021, whichljay889started, "as the other thread is extremely long."

https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/Company-Reviews--and-beyond

At some pointEDSOSLO858took up the mantel and would create the reviews thread, and I would post the reviews in his.

https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/REAL-WOMEN-HAVE-CURVES-Reviews

(There was one time when I started a separate Reviews thread when one had already been started, but that was because the original had already become bogged down in several pages of bickering and arguing before the first review was even posted (as people started offering their predictions on what the reviews would be, and then others argued, etc. etc). So by the time I had the first review, I just started with a new thread for a clean slate than post it on page 3 of a thread filled with bickering. If I remember which one it was, I'll add the link.)

Everything was fine until recent months, when another poster started competing to start the Reviews thread, often afterEDSOSLO858had posted one. So there would be multiple threads, one of which would eventually come out on top.

On Tuesday, at the top of Page 3 of The Fantasticks preview threadEDSOSLO858suddenly announced, "At the request of multiple users, I will start to consolidate preview and review threads for Broadway shows." and changed the title of his thread to Previews + Reviews. I'm not sure why he or the users who apparently requested it get to unilaterally make that decision, but I replied that I would continue to post the reviews in their own thread, the same way they had always been, for the reasons I mentioned at the top of this post. For what little it may be worth, my comment did receive more positive votes than his announcement, so it seems like there was interest in having a separate reviews thread (though one poster did become abusive and demanded everything be in a single thread). CoffeeBreak had in fact already created a separate reviews thread 12 hours earlier, so I did post the reviews there.

https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/THE-FANTASTICKS-Previews/3

https://forum.broadwayworld.com/thread/THE-FANTASTICKS-Hayes-Broadway-Reviews

Last night the ever competitive CoffeeBreak, who had started the previews thread for Much Ado About Nothing, changed the title of the thread from previews to "Previews + Reviews" likeEDSOSLO858had done with The Fantasticks. When I was ready to post the first review, there was no dedicated reviews thread the way there has always been, so I started one and began posting the reviews there, the same way I always have, in their own thread. Some users evidently considered it bizarre to post reviews the exact way we have been for decades (and the abusive poster from the Fantasticks thread reemerged to harangue anyone who thinks reviews should have a separate thread), but there it is. It wasn't about being the first one to create a thread. If anyone else had already started one, I would have used it. But there was not, and I very much believe it's worth having a reviews thread that starts with the opening night reviews and then continues the discussion of the show post-opening from there.

If there's widespread agreement that there should only be one thread for every single post about a show, then so be it. (If anything that seems like it would make things more insular and lead to less engagement, but others claim to know better.) I'm not sure how having two threads, one for previews, one for reviews, is clogging the boards or why people can't simply disregard the thread they're not interested in, yet here we are. But surely it isn't up to a small group of posters to unilaterally make that decision, demand everyone else abide by it, and harass them if they don't?
"

Once again - if you have to write a novel to justify this mess, then you’re the problem.

#12

Re: The show thread war

I generally don't create any of these types of thread, but personally I do prefer separate threads for initial news/speculation, for previews, and for reviews. I remember once wanting to look up old reviews of 'Waitress' in the UK on Theatreboard. Made it to about page 35 of a 70+ page thread and was still on casting speculation etc, and gave up. I would prefer not to have that here. And let's face it, threads go off the rails often enough that an occasional reset can be helpful. But, if those all-in-one threads are used and preferred by others, I'll go with the flow.

#13

Re: The show thread war

So me abiding by the established norms of the board as they existed as recently as 3 days ago is the problem, not those who decided to change them on a whim and/or are being abusive to others? Okay.

The block function exists for a reason. Feel free to use it.

#14

Re: The show thread war

Personally, I prefer having a single thread for a show. I get to NY 2-3 times a year for theater binges, and in deciding what to see I like to review the threads on this board, and particularly the reactions of a few users with whom I've found I tend to agree. Maybe those users saw the show in previews, maybe post-opening. But I'd prefer not to have to seek out and scroll through three or more separate threads on the same show to see reactions and reviews. This is especially true given this site's god-awful search function, which sometimes makes locating those earlier threads near impossible. And if the thread is a long one and I'm looking for something like opening night reviews, I'm perfectly capable of skipping forward or back a few pages to find what I need.

As I said, that's just my personal preference, and I get that others who are looking for different things on this board might have a different one. But one thing I hope we can all agree on is that this juvenile race and competition to be the first creator of a new thread isn't doing anyone any favors and really should stop now.
#15

Re: The show thread war

Yeah I'm confused as to why this has suddenly become an issue after so many years. No one way is going to be perfect or have 100% approval but the imperfect informal way had at the very least been manageable for a very long time.




"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."

Updated On: 11/20/26 at 03:09 PM

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67