Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

ROPE - (Off Broadway) The New Group — Page 2

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#26

Re: ROPE - (Off Broadway) The New Group

quizking101 said: "…I see you’re “new” here. What, pray tell, is giving the idea that there is “love and positive reviews”? At best, I would say we’re polite, if lukewarm."

have you seen the reviews left on show-score? i’m not saying this thread is where i’ve read positive comments. i was just writing down my review/opinion. sorry if i confused you.

#27

Re: ROPE - (Off Broadway) The New Group

I enjoyed this. I found it well acted-particularly the two leads. It has a very classic vibe but I thought it work. I agree the beginning of actors moving the furniture into place made no sense. It was the most smoking I’d seen onstage in a really long time.

#28

Re: ROPE - (Off Broadway) The New Group

Patrick Hamilton is such a great writer (although I think a better novelist than playwright). Why do North American theaters want to do doodles all over his work? Just write something new if you want to “make it more queer or feminist” because you can’t see into the brilliant darkness of the original writer’s work.

Updated On: 10/26/26 at 09:33 AM

#29

Re: ROPE - (Off Broadway) The New Group

This is so dumb. Hahaha. Shaw did a production of Rope mostly as written, less than 10 years ago, and it played like gangbusters. It was still very queer and quite suspenseful. As stated, why not just write something completely new? Or, at most, some judicious pruning? At the very least... just do Never the Sinner?

Lame.


Jesus saves. I spend.
#30

Re: ROPE - (Off Broadway) The New Group

anyone went to yesterdays show? the website said they would be a post show talkback but all the actors left the stage and that was it.
#32

Re: ROPE - (Off Broadway) The New Group

Ensemble17928495872 said: "anyone went to yesterdays show? the website said they would be a post show talkback but all the actors left the stage and that was it."

Was at the show last night at they announced the talkback after curtain call, but I was among those that left.

Overall, it was enjoyable but as someone not familiar with the background of the piece, I also didn't really get what it was trying to say. Some strong performances overall - Liz Gilles was a stunner - but what they were working with was middling for about the first half of the show.

Also, definitely sit further back if you can. I sat in Row B and could barely see below chest level half the time, and with so many scenes were extreme downstage left and right, I can craning my neck to the left or right and hoping to see between Row A's heads - and I'm almost 6 ft. Also on the extreme sides you could't see anything on the wall in front of you, because it was placed fully facing the stage.

Also, if the person Row B center who had their phone out the entire show is reading this, you suck. Because the show was so dark and focused it was impossible to find an usher or reach out the person without distraction.




"Hey little girls, look at all the men in shiny shirts and no wives!" - Jackie Hoffman, Xanadu, 19 Feb 2008
#33

Re: ROPE - (Off Broadway) The New Group

I see many of the reviewers have the same observations i had. I thought some of it might get ironed out in previews especially the lack of suspense and motives. I would post some links to reviews, but I can’t seem to do it.

#34

Re: ROPE - (Off Broadway) The New Group

I was there last night but didn't stay for the talkback, primarily because the director was scheduled to participate. In my opinion, the direction was where this production suffered most.

When this revival was announced, I knew my hubs would want to see it, being a big fan of the film adaptation. We rewatched the movie about a month ago, and I was excited to see a fresh interpretation, especially with this casting.

I thought the script was strong and appreciated the inclusion of the stage-version flashbacks that aren't in the film. The stage business was also successful. But once again, the direction felt lazy and uninspired, ultimately doing a disservice to the performances of the two leads.

Where was the fun? Where was the excitement?

My immediate thought was how much fun it could have been to play the group party scenes as full-on melodrama (a nod to the play's origins), while making the one-on-one flashbacks feel almost hyperrealistic. The party is, after all, a charade, and leaning into that theatricality could have been an exciting direction to explore. The flashbacks, on the other hand, give the audience a glimpse into the true nature of these characters. Playing those moments completely straight could have made them land with much greater emotional impact. This could have added to the subversive homosexuality of these scenes.

There was an opportunity here to create a really interesting contrast between the public performance these characters put on and who they actually are behind closed doors. I just don't think this production ever fully explored it.
#35

Re: ROPE - (Off Broadway) The New Group

i wish gordon greenberg would stop talking about this script, every time he opens his mouth i regret more and more that i gave him money to watch the play. his latest interview confirms the only thing he had in mind was to make it gay /sexual and horny for whoever is into just that. he needs to study more on the real events that inspired the original play because he can’t just say with his whole chest that we don’t know what their true intentions were and we only have theories. we DO know those pricks thought they were the smartest people on earth and decided to randomly murder a kid. the poor victim and his family will never rest as long as people like him are out there making SH*T up to get richer.
#36

Re: ROPE - (Off Broadway) The New Group

sinister teashop said: "Patrick Hamilton is such a great writer (although I think a better novelist than playwright). Why do North American theaters want to do doodles all over his work? Just write something new if you want to “make it more queer or feminist” because you can’t see into the brilliant darkness of the original writer’s work."

Yeah, i don't quite get what Greenberg was doing. The production is handsome and has some fun moments, but overall, the gay subtext was turned into hammer-over-the-head moments that didnt really add a whole lot. My biggest gripe is that they took great efforts to add the gay angle, and to turn the two leads into Jews-trying-to-pass, and even move the story up a few decades, but then they stick with this old-timey awkward 1950s cadence and dialogue that weighs the whole piece down especially during the first half. Theres alot of "trying hard" here that doesnt help the piece. As others have mentioned, two actors spend the first 3 minutes silently moving the set pieces around and getting dressed because..... sure.

Lotta fine actors here but the only successful bright spots, in very small roles, were Graham Phillips and especially Elizabeth GIllies, who overcome some awkward dialogue and are delightful. Gillies especially is doing incredible work with her few scenes.

Latest Posts

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71