I saw tonights performance. I do think this show has the potential to be spectacular, however, as it is right now, a lot of work still needs to be done.
Main issues - the music. The score was strong, the lyrics were not. A lot of it felt very forced, making scenes awkward. It seemed the characters were suddenly thrust out of the moment by having to sing all of their feelings. A lot of what could have been dialogue was forced into song in an almost unnatural way. It ruined what could have been a nice, smooth flowing scene into a choppy mess.
Also, in relation to the score, most of it was forgettable. Yes, it was nice and was era appropriate, but it was not catchy or memorable. As I sit here typing this, I honestly can't recollect any part of any one song. When music has the power to carry over off the stage and into your minds and stick with you, it has truly suceeded. Maybe I'm the only one who felt this way, though.
I wish there was more focus on Celie and her character's struggles. Partially because LaChanze truly is remarkable and all her talent should be capitalized on (without taking focus off the story, of course), but also because Celie is such a central, foundational character that without it being well developed, so much is lost in the understanding of her journey and her will.
A smaller issues I had was the muffling of the sound and the dialogue. A lot seemed mumbled. The people around me at intermission agreed that they wished they could understand more of the dialogue and hear better. But those are just little things I'm sure will be fixed as previews continue.
There are a lot of elements the show has going for it. The ENTIRE cast was very strong, very talented. Not a weak link in the bunch. The choreography was indeed fantastic. I especially loved the African dancing, though the breast revealing costumes and the thongs took me a moment to take in (family show?). I expected to walk away really remembering LaChanze, but it was Felicia as Sophia that stole the show for me. Every moment she was on stage, she commanded your attention.
Right now, i'd say it is an amazing production which suffers from a poorly developed book and sloppily thrown together character expose. In trying to translate every element of the story onto the stage, something was a lost. A feeling, a rawness, something I can't quite put my finger one. But with some pulling tightening and focusing, it can go very far. I do definitely encourage all to see it, and I will be going back to see it after it's set to see how it has come along. Maybe it won't be 3 hours by then!
Updated On: 11/3/05 at 12:03 AM