I saw the final dress yesterday @ 2. my thoughts are almost the same as penguins. I really liked it, but I wanted to be blown away by the vision. I think my expectations were a little TOO high. that being said, I still thought it was very good. with a little tweaking over the preview period, it can be brilliant.
if you are planning to go, don't sit on the sides. the set is symmetrical, and will be a better experience if you can see what is happening on both sides.
What I loved- the vocal direction on all the chorus numbers- the singers are so strong and sound great together singing those chords on "we Looooooooove you"
I loved the little things you do together, you could drive a person crazy, someone is waiting, side by side, poor baby, Barcelona, and of course, being alive, in which Raul is quite exceptional. his voice is so strong, but when he pulls back, it is beautiful, filled with subtext, and disarming. this was my first time seeing him live, and I am now a fan. he deeply impressed me.
some things worked, some didn't. Doyle left room for applause after some songs, and didn't after others. Sometimes it was awkward, like after the great opening, they went right into the scene, and the audience didn't know what to think. I know Doyle had to do that after the first song to set up how the evening would go.
But I wanted to applaud after some of the great performances, and It just felt weird to me not to be able to.
The pacing in some places will need to be picked up. sometimes there were lulls, and sometimes dramatic pauses lasted a little too long for me, but it can all be forgiven because of the wonderful cast, concept, and direction.
Sondheim was there in the 3rd. or 4th row. of the orch. yesterday, with Doyle sitting in the mezz on the right side. and as the show ended, Doyle got right up, and passed by, scanning the audience's expressions. I loved watching that moment.
funny story- when I got to the theatre, there were about 2-300 playbills of "Ring of Fire" that had never been bothered to be discarded. I just found it funny, and thought that maybe the show was just too horrible to clean up afterward.
"I'm an American, Damnit!!! And if it's three things I don't believe in, it's quitting and math."