Wow, another ironic tony occurance, Both Kelli and Celia were nominated in the same category, and Bill Cudrup and MLP were both nominated...... Updated On: 6/7/05 at 11:32 AM
Actually - I saw Celia play the role in Chicago and she was just lovely. From what I've seen in interviews, she doesn't give herself nearly enough credit. I haven't seen O'Hara and I'm sure she's terrific in the part, but Celia was dynamite as well.
Regardless of the circumstances involved, I think it's wonderful that two great performers both found a home in productions that allowed them to break through. That almost never happens in this business.
I must say Celia is a FIERCE actress. She was WONDERFUL in piazza. However, Kelli sings the role a bit easier and clearer and better. Celia played Joanna in Sweeney. I think she's a soprano. According to an interview with Victoria Clark, one of the reasons they went with someone else was because Celia just plays really young. They tried all sorts of things to change her, but Kelli reads as a woman in her 20's as opposed to Celia who reads about 20. But then again this is more speculation. Adam is for a fact one of the nicest guys though.
Such a tragedy this man is heterosexual. Deep sigh here. Now, it just may be me and my weakness for educated Bronx accents, but did John Patrick Shanley look kinda hot on the Tony's?? Funny, in all his pictures he looks like crap, but for an older guy.....Yeh, I'd do im. Nice to see he's out of his depressing, Clifford Odets-esque Hollywood glut.
"Impossible is just a big word thrown around by small men who find it easier to live in the world they've been given than to explore the power they have to change it. Impossible is not a fact. It's an opinion. Impossible is not a declaration. It's a dare. Impossible is potential. Impossible is temporary. Impossible is nothing.”
~ Muhammad Ali
No the show says that Clara is mentally 12 but her body is 26. Celia doesn't read as 26 onstage. She's not actually 12. Besides, that's Vikki Clark's reason. I think it was probably a factor. Anyway if anyone would know, she would be one of them.
"Clifford Odets-esque Hollywood glut" - what a great description borstalboy!
Clara should look 26 but have the mind of a 12 year old. I think they are saying that Clara should be 26 on appearance. Even that's how old Celia is, she doesn't appear to be 26 physically. Though I do think that she shouldn't "read" to be 26. I think she should "read" younger - it helps.
OK. Although, I sat 10 feet from Celia at the 'Summer of '42' concert last month, and she looked mid-20's to me. I've never seen Celia in a show, but she's got stage presence and wonderful comic timing.
I'm a straight, married man with kids...but Adam Guettel has been my man-crush for many years. I would love to spend an afternoon just talking to the guy. He is so articulate and so moody, we'd get along great.
Updated On: 6/7/05 at 01:13 PM
see what happens when you try to chime in on these discussions?
seriously, I'm not into Adam Guettel because he's good looking (though he obviously is), I'm into him because he's the most talented person I've ever heard, whose music really moved me the moment I first heard Floyd Collins (thus the reference in my avatar to waiting 9 years for his Tony), and who seems (from the dozens of interviews I've read) to be a very articulate, self-aware guy who knows he's talented but still has the same doubts the rest of us do.
THOSE qualities are what make him the kind of guy I'd like to hang out with for a day.
I had the extreme pleasure of meeting Mr. Guettel in the lobby before the show and he was not drunk at all just very nervous and excited. And very nice, Congrats!
I just want to say that I am in love with Adam Guettel. Thank you very much.
Not that I have a chance in hell with him but I love that he's straight. He's not just so gorgeous but he's so talented. I love his music as much as the rest of him. *fans self*
"I'm the STAR!"--Daniel Reichard during Glory Daze sound check