I need a towel for my chair--CHRIS is on my tv!
Chris is truly gifted to make me able to listen to a Creed song without getting the urge to punch my TV.
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/16/05
Damn, he is a pretty man.
but is it too much to ask for it to be in tune?
These comments from Simon who would say no to people in the first round auditions for having too much range. These comments from someone who tells contestants to hone in on what they do best and what kind of artist they want to be.
I think Simon is right 95% of the time, but he can be so inconsistent and when he's wrong, he is WRONG.
Katharine started the song really off and never quite recovered. She should thank her lucky stars that Lisa essentially did the same thing times 10 about 35 minutes ago.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/10/05
no one has been good tonight, no one. oh, and the idiot who sang Drops of Jupiter needs to go, that was a awful.
Wow. A lot of these people sound awful. Can they not hear the music on stage or what?
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/16/05
er. Paula, honey, that was NOT good. Mediocre at best.
Is it me or did Ryan not mention Paula Abdul as he introduced the judges? I believe I heard, and say hello to "Randy & Simon."
I agree, jerby. One week he tells him that he likes the fact that he knows who he is and respects him for being true to himself, and tonight he tells him he can't keep doing the same thing week after week. Huh?
Chris is hotter than hell!!! He's the next American Idol. And if he's not... well, then he's not. No one ever went broke under estimating the intelligence of the American public.
While I didn't think Chris delivered a great performance tonight, I do agree that Simon was being inconsistant with his critique. Either you respect him for being who he is, or you encourage him to do something different.
I also think Katharine is terribly overrated. That was mediocre at best. Everyone's doing poorly tonight!
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/10/05
can they get rid of 3 people this week please? Ace, Carrie and this goofy looking, goofier sounding bucky guy?
Bucky wasn't quite as Sucky as usual, but still should have gone home already. And why was he doing the Electric Slide across the stage mid-song?
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/2/04
My sentiments exactly, Allie.
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/16/05
That was a dreadful song, she did well with what she had, but that song is just so freaking awful.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/10/05
Paris was really good. I liked it, one good performance.
Katharine is my favorite, but tonight she was NOT good
Thank you, Chica and Luscious. I thought I was going deaf or was just especially grumpy tonight, but I certainly don't think that was "better than Christina" Aguilera. That wasn't even better than Christina Applegate.
Videos