#76
Posted: 7/22/07 at 3:36pm
I’m a little confused as to what some people wanted from this tale. This woman has woven a fantastical myth for the ages, and one which hopefully is meant to inspire. You want cynicism and despair? Don’t look to her works, look in a mirror.
Being sort of unsure about the epilogue doesn't mean that we wanted cynicism and despair. I even said that I loved the epilogue conceptually because Harry and his friends weren't going to be damaged by the war when the only things they ever fought for were freedom and the safety of family and friends. It's perfect to have our final look at those characters, especially Harry, be them with what they always wanted and showcasing the highest ideals of the series. I just think that it could have been written with a little more clarity and elaboration.
If you ask me why I said, before reading the book, that I thought that Harry would die, my answer would be the same as the reason that he walked willingly to meet his fate once he knew it (which was altogether gut-wrenching to read). If Voldemort was right about anything, it was that Harry isn't the type to let other people continue to die for him. There's no way I'd expect anything less. The fact that Rowling delivered this willingness without sacrificing the character's life and without my feeling as a reader that it was somehow cheating is really a testament to her skill in setting up this series.
But he DID, really. It's only since Harry's blood was used to bring back Voldemort at the end of GoF that Voldemort started preserving part of his soul, correct? (I can't double-check because both my parents have to get through the book...) But if I'm remember that correctly, then up until the end of the fourth book (with the infamous "gleam of triumph"), Dumbledore WAS planning for Harry to die, believing him to be the final Horcrux.
Entirely the way I saw it, too. I think that Dumbledore was absolutely fascinating in this book, because.... even if Harry hadn't have the protection of his mother's blood and would have died, I'm honestly not sure how Dumbledore's plans for him would've changed. He might have been determined to do it himself and therefore less reckless with something like the Resurrection Stone, but if it had to come down to Voldemort and Harry... But I love Dumbledore beyond words, and believe that he loves Harry enough that he'd find another way or else be completely straight with Harry about the way it would have to go. Because the case was that Harry had to believe that he'd certainly die, it makes sense that Dumbledore only gave him part of the story. I'm so pleased with that as an explanation for the much-speculated-about "gleam of triumph."
Being sort of unsure about the epilogue doesn't mean that we wanted cynicism and despair. I even said that I loved the epilogue conceptually because Harry and his friends weren't going to be damaged by the war when the only things they ever fought for were freedom and the safety of family and friends. It's perfect to have our final look at those characters, especially Harry, be them with what they always wanted and showcasing the highest ideals of the series. I just think that it could have been written with a little more clarity and elaboration.
If you ask me why I said, before reading the book, that I thought that Harry would die, my answer would be the same as the reason that he walked willingly to meet his fate once he knew it (which was altogether gut-wrenching to read). If Voldemort was right about anything, it was that Harry isn't the type to let other people continue to die for him. There's no way I'd expect anything less. The fact that Rowling delivered this willingness without sacrificing the character's life and without my feeling as a reader that it was somehow cheating is really a testament to her skill in setting up this series.
But he DID, really. It's only since Harry's blood was used to bring back Voldemort at the end of GoF that Voldemort started preserving part of his soul, correct? (I can't double-check because both my parents have to get through the book...) But if I'm remember that correctly, then up until the end of the fourth book (with the infamous "gleam of triumph"), Dumbledore WAS planning for Harry to die, believing him to be the final Horcrux.
Entirely the way I saw it, too. I think that Dumbledore was absolutely fascinating in this book, because.... even if Harry hadn't have the protection of his mother's blood and would have died, I'm honestly not sure how Dumbledore's plans for him would've changed. He might have been determined to do it himself and therefore less reckless with something like the Resurrection Stone, but if it had to come down to Voldemort and Harry... But I love Dumbledore beyond words, and believe that he loves Harry enough that he'd find another way or else be completely straight with Harry about the way it would have to go. Because the case was that Harry had to believe that he'd certainly die, it makes sense that Dumbledore only gave him part of the story. I'm so pleased with that as an explanation for the much-speculated-about "gleam of triumph."
Updated On: 7/22/07 at 03:36 PM