If the New York Times story is correct, I guess that the Great Comet mash-up would be "Dust and Ashes" and "Balaga." Am I assuming too much? That seems weird, and I am pretty skeptical of combo platter Tony performances unless there's enough time (which there won't be). But I'm still curious how they would pull it off. Which song would go first?
The Dear Evan Hansen producers would be making the smart decision with "Waving Through a Window." It's a little on the nose, but it's the best standalone song in the musical and would reflect well both on Ben Platt and on the show itself.
As for Hello, Dolly, the producers really think they have more bargaining power than they actually do. Shoot, it's already clear - based on the discounts being offered on TodayTix - that without Bette Midler, nobody really cares about Dolly. Nobody is going to tune in to watch David Hyde Pierce sing a song nobody's ever heard of, that wasn't even in the original show. (No disrespect to David Hyde Pierce.)
Let's be real. Tony ratings are almost always weak, unless you have a powerhouse like Hamilton driving the ratings. They'll be weak with Midler. They'll have even less to promote without her.
Frankly, this sort of thing is what's wrong with Broadway. I didn't see Hello, Dolly on my recent trip to New York, but I would certainly have been curious to see Midler's performance in the biggest hit of this season that I've read many positive things about on these boards. Broadway can keep its little club small and exclusive, or it can try to reach new audiences. The Hamilton producers, who could have demanded all sorts of concessions last year, used the Tony Awards to promote their hot show and they are being rewarded with sellout crowds across the country. Hello, Dolly is afraid to expose its experienced performer to a national audience.
That's really lame.