My compelling question remains: What songs will Great Comet mash up, and how in the world can it possibly work? If we're going to get a Groban ballad, it must be a shortened version of "Dust and Ashes" because I doubt they would do "Pierre" without the Prologue and they wouldn't do the last song. And the dance song must be "Balaga," right?
How would they work in combination, with all the controlled chaos that sounds like it's being planned? It could be brilliant, it could be a total mess, it will probably be a brilliant, truncated mess. I'm still very skeptical about medleys in these shows, but I'm very curious how they will try to pull it off. Are my guesses way off? A Balaga/Dust and Ashes mashup seems a bit odd; they're just educated guesses based on the New York Times story.
Random thoughts...
- I agree with the Dear Evan Hansen producers. "Waving Through a Window" is the best standalone song in the show. Most viewers haven't seen every TV performance of the show or even heard any songs from it.
- Last year, I was a little disappointed in Hamilton's choice of "Yorktown," as the musical has better songs. I always wished for "The Room Where it Happens," because it's my favorite song in the show and because Leslie Odom Jr. would have brought down the house. But with the producers emphasizing the show as the star, I understood the logic of "Yorktown," with its emphasis on the ensemble and the choreography. Plus, having just seen it Saturday night on tour, I was reminded that "Yorktown" is pretty awesome and works as a standalone crowdpleaser. It was a smart choice, given the producers' plans to position Hamilton for long-term success, even if it's not what I personally would have chosen.
Updated On: 5/31/17 at 01:35 AM