Yes, it needed work especially in Act II, but at the state it was in, Bronx Tale was much better than the bland, boring Waitress. Cordero would do himself a favor and ditch that Waitress role for a musical that shows off his talent. I'm sure he would go with Bronx Tale.
P.S. I'm surprised that Waitress is doing so well. It is so horribly ordinary and sleep inducing with a score that runs together and almost becomes one long, lulling lullabye.