Saw this last night. I went in with lowered expectations after reading all the complaints here. It tells a compelling story fairly well. I enjoyed it. I haven't seen the film in a very long time so it had me engaged, as I couldn't remember the particulars of the story. Do I wish we could have time traveled 1992 Demi Moore in for the role of Galloway? Yes. But who today is the calibre of 1992 Demi Moore? For me Tom Blyth was both charismatic & handsome enough so that I wasn't thinking about Tom Cruise. (And these days I never think about that guy.)
Unfortunately, the biggest star from this show barely turns up. The famous line is emblazoned on t-shirts & baseball caps at the merch stand - "YOU CAN'T HANDLE THE TRUTH" - but when it comes in the play it is with a whimper instead of a bang. It is probably a bit embarrassing for Mr. Sorkin that the most famous line from his entire career wasn't actually written by him, but was improvised by Jack Nicholson on set.
The play is all a bit of TV lawyer - Perry Mason cracking the case and getting the witness to confess on the stand. It does it well. But Perry Mason still does it well nightly at midnight on MeTV. So the biggest question probably is "Why now?" This revival's inception (!) was likely when those involved who know the work well began to see so many real world parallels to this nearly 40 year old play - like First Lieutenant Kendrick who uses his twisted sel-righteous religious beliefs to justify his actions. It's like we're looking at the Pentagon of today. So this nearly 40 year old play presents an idealistic tale of a charming lawyer & Justice (capitalized) triumphing over those who over-step themselves and arrogantly flout the rule of law. Do they expect someone in power now to see this on Broadway and think to themselves, "Hey maybe we should hold today's arrogant individuals who are flouting the rules of law to account!" That would be nice, but somehow I doubt a play revival will do that.
It would be interesting to hear from those who saw the original production, and if they could remember if the original was so homoerotic? Here's a link to the original playbill:
https://playbill.com/production/a-few-good-men-music-box-theatre-vault-0000002585
Pretty tame compared to the Tom of Finland-like logo used for this production. You can be sure that I bought a window card! The set, a large aircraft hanger, could pass for a Steamworks bath house; and all the uniforms bring us to any popular fetish night. Dress whites for your next White Party? Yes please, Daddy!
I love it when a director can bring out the gay subtext in a piece. With the Lost Boys I wanted Michael Arden to go further, but I'm sure producers wanted a family-friendly piece. Here he was restrained by the script.
We know today more than was obvious in 1989 what goes on - look at how many of today's biggest gay porn & OF stars are ex-military, covered in Marine Corp tattoos. Some are pretty troubled, no doubt dealing with PTSD in the absolutely wrong way. I can't help thinking about Scott Finn who shot himself in the head last December in Utah at only 27 years of age. So sad.
But a director who does bring out the gay subtext in a popular piece puts a target on their back for online purveyors of rumour and innuendo. For example, month's ago the Sweaty @sshole was making all kinds of unlitigatable allegations on social media that some director was "casting couching" young male Broadway actors. What came of his supposed expose? I don't know, I stopped following him. But what do you want? Do you want some tubby old man like me playing members of the Marine Corp? No, you want all the beef cake cast here. (At least I do.) But I certainly also expect that a production asking the audience to hold the military to account for improprieties, would have measures in place to ensure that nothing inappropriate took place during their casting and rehearsal period. I hope my confidence in the members of this production has not been misplaced.
If there something more compelling playing that I hadn't already seen, maybe I would choose to see that over this. But for me this was a satisfactory night at the theater.
...