Finally listened through the whole thing.
Comparatively speaking, both Ushers (Owens and Spivey) have their strengths and weaknesses when it comes to the score. Owens was able to bring bombast and cheekiness to numbers like “Exile In Gayville” and “Writing A Gospel Play”, but lacked vulnerability and quietness for the songs toward the end of the show, which I handily tip the hat to Spivey.
I will say that there were some moments on the OCR that were missing on the OBCR - most notably in “Tyler Perry Writes Real Life”. Considering James Jackson Jr. EATS UP the Harriet Tubman role on stage, I was surprised at how muted it felt on recording and it was a bit of a letdown. Also, with “Exile In Gayville”, the different “profiles” felt sped through and didn’t land like they did on the OCR or live.
L. Morgan Lee still knocks out “A Sympathetic Ear”, but I think the real MVP of the album is John-Andrew Morrison. His performance on the OBCR was unequivocally the most consistently good and unchanged across all three mediums and each time I listen to “Periodically”, I find myself rooting for him more and more over Matt Doyle for the Featured Actor Tony (which, honestly, he may actually nail down since Doyle picked up all the awards Morrison was already previously eligible for in 2020).
The comparisons, however, will never erase the fact that this is a must-listen score and it’s importance and originality cannot be overstated.
Check out my eBay page for sales on Playbills!!
www.ebay.com/usr/missvirginiahamm