It's funny: I have the Vegas sitdown of Avenue Q to thank for introducing me to the show (saw it three times at the Wynn), but it was arguably a step backward for a show that could've been truly, truly huge. Like Tag said, the missed opportunities of different city sitdowns and a touring production in '05 were enormous. While the show still made bank in the long-run,no doubt, I can't imagine what the show could've done with a wider audience at its height spreading. IIRC, the producers were fishing for a television deal to bring the project full circle and Jeff Marx said there was also talks of a film version. I have to imagine Vegas all but flushed those hopes down the drain, and it just became a successful Broadway musical. Life goes on, I guess.
bdn223 said: "haterobics said: "bdn223 said: "
Avenue Q is also rarely given its dueas a generation defining musical aking to Rent, Hair, American Idiot, and now Dear Evan Hansen.Its the comming of age/generation defining/seat at the tablemusical of late GenXers and early Millenials who came of age before 9/11with its satire of being a generation raised by television."
Which brings me to this, because you're right: Avenue Q was the first musical to truly go viral. It seemed perfectly on-point, speaking on both a relatable and satirical level in a way that most generation-defining musicals never had before. (and arguably, still have not) Not only did it have that parodic edge to appeal to those millennials freshly out of college, but it also talked directly to them as well. Many of these types of musicals tend to be self-important anthems (pretty much almost all of the ones above that you listed) at heart, but Avenue Q decided to be charming and irreverent instead, and still delivered a great message.
That said, its time has probably come. I don't really get what the producers are saying about not being able to fit in with all of "the great shows ahead" (literally this could be said ahead of any season, ever), so my best guess is that NWS wanted a new show in and this one had been holding residence for the longest at 10 years.
I'd be amused if it tours, I'm not really sure if the demand is there? The show is a little dated (though don't get me wrong, as a piece of musical comedy it holds up supremely) and creaky just by standards of being essentially an internet meme from 2004/5. You can find productions of it about everywhere you go, and that about kills everything that isn't Disney. It'll be strange having such an iconic production finally die, but y'know, reference to the song at the end of the show here.
I hope with this Rick Lyon can finally start fully licensing community theater productions to use his puppets because yeesh some of those knockoff ones are horrific.