"So you've never heard of a bootleg? A cast album? I think what you're saying is irrelevant because its very easy these days to tell if a show a better than another without seeing it live."
I believe we are all talking about LIVE theater...which is what the Tony awards represent. If we are talking about filmed versions or recorded versions, you probably should be talking about the Emmy's or the Grammy's.
If someone is discussing LIVE theater and makes a judgement based on anything other than LIVE theater, that opinion is definitely irrelevant.