I have never seen the stage show. It never looked like something I wanted to see. But the movie came out and seeing that was gonna be easier than seeing a show, so I rented this and now...I want to buy it. It was that good. Everything in the movie was perfect. Perfect starting song with a character I was perhaps a little annoyed at how whiny and weak he seemed, but then I felt sorry for him and was on his side. Absolutely fantastic opening song. I realized Ben Platt is a far better singer than I could ever hope to be and it wasn't just the song that was good but his voice. Colton Ryan was adorable as the troubled kid Evan gets involved with and I secretly wished there was a romance between them (and you almost feel their made up friendship could have been). Amy Adams was such a dear mother, I really liked her, except for one bit I'll get to later. Nik Dodani was, well, a character I didn't like because he was a mean friend to Evan. I didn't understand why he even talked to Evan if he didn't want to be associated with him. I liked Kaitlyn Dever. I liked Amandla Stenberg. But really, what was the best was the story, the songs, and Ben Platt's performance. I can see why he won the Tony for best leading actor in a musical, and hope he gets at least some nominations come awards season. I didn't cry, but towards the end when Evan starts really getting to know Connor by looking up stuff about him, and when Connor plays the guitar and his family sees, I did tear up. I didn't like that Connor's mom never stays close to Evan after some time after Evan apologized and later gives her that video, and I didn't get why Amy Adams would smile for a moment when she tells Evan she thinks he should go, but that was it. I can see why this musical won Best Musical and Best Score. Ben Platt did look too old sometimes as to distract me, but was not too old for me to lose myself in this movie, and I say all the critics saying the movie was bad are wrong. This film is a masterpiece. I hope I can buy it, because I heard they may not even release it on Blu-ray because it flopped so hard. The flashbacks to Evan in the tree, and the final flashback of it with the soaring song where we learn what he was really doing was genius. I had no idea the ending with the video of Connor's song was added. I loved that part, it made me tear up, as I said. Yes, I guess there would be no video at a rehab place, but a lot of movies have plot holes but are still good because the scenes with those plot holes are that good, enhance the movie that much, or make you that emotional, and you just get it. Same with the apple orchard plot hole. You could even say it for the entire movie since critics had a hard time accepting the main story. So, yeah, I loved it. It's a flawed masterpiece.
Updated On: 11/18/21 at 01:33 AM