Yeah, I was disappointed.
This is essentially Spencer Kayden's show, and she is fantastic. I hope she gets a Tony nomination. It's a shame that such a brilliant performance and wonderful performer is wasted on such a mediocre production and play.
Jennifer Tilly manages to wring the most laughs she can out of her character, usually just with her unique voice and the hilarious lack of class she gives her character.
However, those are essentially the only two reasons to see this show, in my opinion. Adam James seems to operate under the philosophy, "When in doubt, flail around. When not in doubt... flail around." Ben Daniels didn't really even register for me.
Unlike Matthew Warchus's sleek production of Boeing-Boeing (to which this will obviously be compared, despite the fact this "sequel" has nothing in common with that play aside from the names of its.. protagonists), this production is clunky and moves too slowly in between comic set pieces (of which there aren't many good ones). The text itself is likewise inferior to Boeing-Boeing, not that the bar was set too high to begin with. If anything, this production illuminates what a miracle the Boeing-Boeing revival really was; it was a holy union of savvy directing, wonderful performances, and clever design. This production has only one wonderful performance, truly, and a good performance from Tilly. The design, aside from William Ivey Long's reliably good costumes (Kayden's onstage costume change was a surprising highlight, and Tilly's hat manages to be a better joke than most in the script), is ugly and not even well-utilized.
This production also doesn't mask the piece's datedness or inherent unsavoriness of plot. This is not to say Boeing-Boeing was a shining example of progressive thought... but that production managed to conceal the sexist "too many stewardesses!" tone. This... not so much. The two adulterers that serve as the protagonists get off scot-free, united with their "rightful" partners in a half-hearted resolution. It's fine to do plays such as these, but for god's sake you better do them with such energy and verve that I don't have time to stop and think how unlikeable the protagonists are or how sexist the plot is. I shouldn't have time to stop and think much at all.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."