I saw the show last night but couldn't really write about it until now because it would have just been "OMG SEE THIS SHOW RIGHT NOW!!!" over and over. The sentiment remains true but now I can elucidate a little more.
I can safely say this is one of the best shows I've ever seen. Never have I been more emotionally invested in a story from the beginning to the bitter end. While I wish this show was longer than 100 minutes I don't know if I could have taken much more without breaking down. There were songs where I was dying of laughter (the Fun Home commercial, the Partridge Family sequence), sobbing (Judy Kuhn and Michael Cerveris' numbers) and both (Changing My Major to Joan, the delivery woman song).
The acting is across the board fantastic. As Whizzer said, every person in the cast deserves their own paragraph of heaping praise. Most of the time I find child stage actors to be too precious and twee but these kids were acting far above their ages. Small Alison gives a performance that you would expect from a 30-something because she understands all the nuances in the character. The delivery woman song was actually the highlight of the show for me (followed ever so closely by the Fun Home commercial). For a girl to act the emotion behind that song without having lived through it is actually mind-blowing.
Sadly I didn't get to see the lab production so I can't comment on anyone except Michael Cerveris who I thought did a fantastic job. I haven't really enjoyed anything he's done since SWEENEY TODD but he really delivered here. People seem to love Judy Kuhn who I've only seen in PASSION prior to this. At first I was wondering why she was in this role because it's kind of a throwaway but then her 11 o'clock number was phenomenal.
I thought the set was great and you would probably have a great view from any seat in the house. Great use of the turntable. The one thing I didn't really like were the boxes/lines drawn on the black curtain during the set change. It didn't really add anything and seemed like "hey this is a graphic novel so let's do cartoony stuff."
Obviously I highly recommend the show. I can't wait to go back and think I should rush the show before reviews come out because this will be a hot ticket.
Side Note: Does anyone know if you are limited to one student ticket per show? I know they put your info into the computer when you purchase the ticket but not sure if they keep track.
"Pardon my prior Mcfee slip. I know how to spell her name. I just don't know how to type it." -Talulah