bk,
The only reason I think we were arguing that the audience response was strong was not because we didn't realize there were many comped friends and family in the house, but rather because After Eight didn't want to acknowledge that people genuinely enjoyed themselves. It's ok not to find something funny, but to say that there's no humor in it and therefore deny that anyone could find it funny was the issue. (Also for the record I did pay for my ticket and don't know anyone associated with the production.)
I made sure to quote enough lines because I think with a comedy, especially a raunchy comedy, you can either rave or bash the thing, but since it's all so subjective I wanted to throw out some lines and let people decide for themselves. I almost wanted to compare this to The Hangover, but I couldn't stand that movie so I refrained, but it could be in that vein. There is definitely more of a gay/camp/did that really just happen vibe than in The Hangover, but you're either going to find this stuff funny or hate it. Probably not too much middle ground here.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!